Anthony Bourdain once said, “Russ & Daughters occupies that rare and tiny place on the mountain top reserved for those who are not just the oldest and the last—but also the best.” Indeed, a hush falls over you when walking into Russ & Daughters. It's a feeling akin to walking into a cathedral in Italy because you’re in a place that worships bagels.
For nationwide delivery, a dozen bagels are just $18 plus shipping, the price of which varies by region. You have two choices, plain or assorted, which comes with options like sesame and everything.
But here is where you must splurge: Get yourself some of Russ & Daughter's legendary sturgeon for $60, or smoked salmon starting at $40 for six to eight servings. There's nothing like this “cold-smoked” salmon, which is salt-cured and then preserved with slowly-burned smoke. Its silkiness is unlike any other salmon, and it suddenly transports you to a smoked salmon experience that is halfway between BBQ and a sublime Sushi experience.
A bagel is the sum of so many important parts, from the crisp outside, the lightness of the inside, the crumb, the chew, etc. But very few of us eat bagels without some sort of topping, and we don't want to feel like the topping was an afterthought. Truly, the seed can change the whole quality of eating a bagel—and Davidovich knows that very well: Their seeds are plentifully placed on both sides of the bagel. Plus, if you are a seed connoisseur you can tell they are using the highest quality seeds they can get their hands on.
When perusing the site, you'll notice the ample options of bagels. A five-pack of everything bagels—overflowing with seeds—is $7.99. You can also order 20 bagels that combine plain, sesame, poppy, and everything varieties for $34.99. There are several options for shipping, but orders placed to California and Florida must be upgraded to standard overnight shipping to preserve freshness.
You can’t avoid talking about Bagels without mentioning Katz’s, one of the most classic delis in all of New York City. They’ve been around since 1888—and in that time nothing has changed about a Katz’s bagel since the moment it was conceived. That means you're getting the highest quality, most consistent bagels around.
Once on their easy-to-navigate website, you'll find bagels, rye, mustard, and more, but what you want are the New York Bagels, a bagel that exemplifies the crispy, fluffy tear of the New York style. You can choose between plain, poppy, sesame, or everything, and a half-dozen costs $10.
Shipping costs between $35 and $60 since Katz’s demands that they ship fast to ensure quality and freshness. They even have Bialys, a delicious cousin to the bagel that is without a hole.
And while this isn’t a 'best pastrami delivery' list, we recommend that you carve off some pastrami for your order while you’re grabbing these bagels and have a real deli experience at home. A pound of the juicy, sliced pastrami is just $35.
St. Viateur is basically the platonic-ideal of the Montreal-style bagel, the second most popular regional style of bagel behind the New York-style ones that fill most of the other spots on this list. Compared to New York bagels, they’re smaller, thinner, sweeter, denser, and come with a larger hole.
These bagels are lovingly crafted by Joe Morena and his three sons Vincenzo, Nicolo, and Roberto. The specific shape of bagels the family created, known for its crannies and twists, makes you want to dive right in, and they scream "hand-made-to-perfection."
They offer all the classics of bagels—sesame, poppy, plain, whole wheat, cinnamon raisin, and rosemary & salt. They even call the Everything Bagel “All Dressed,” in classic Canadian fashion.
On the order page, you can get two dozen, four dozen, six dozen, or nine dozen bagels.Two dozen is $49, four dozen is $69, six dozen is $99, and nine dozen is $139. Free shipping is offered through Goldbelly.
The Bagel Nook comes to our list as an alien from the future because we have never seen anyone push expectations of what a bagel is supposed to be the way they do.
Their biggest hit is the Oreo and Cream Cheese bagel—yes, they're full Oreos in the middle of this Frankenstein-bagel, with Oreo cream cheese and Oreo dough. They also make Fruity Pebble and Cocoa Puff bagels with both of those breakfast cereals included in the cream cheese. There’s a French Toast Bagel, a unicorn-colored Tie Dye bagel, and so much more.
If you're looking for something more savory but just as adventurous, they have a Hot Cheetos bagel. The bagel itself is neon orange and red, comes with your choice of Cool Ranch cream cheese or Ghost Pepper cream cheese, and, of course, is packed with Flaming Hot Cheetos inside.
Head to Goldbelly and find The Bagel Nook if you want to order. Prices range from $39 for a dozen of tie dye bagels, to $79 for a dozen of overloaded fruity pebbles bagel and cream cheese.
Bagels aren’t supposed to be soft. That's not how New Yorkers want them: They want to chip their tooth on the delicious, crunchy outer crust. That's just the New York way. They don’t mind a little difficulty when eating their bagel.
That’s the essence of Bagel Hole, a shop that's making bagels the old school way. At first glance, these bagels are a little too small, a little too hard on the outside, and a little too chewy on the inside, but why can’t you get them out of your mind? Because these bagels represent a masterful old style of making bagels.
Bagel Hole now brings their crusty New York experience to your front door. On the website, you click on a bagel you want, and one by one you keep clicking to add the bagel to your bag. Nowhere else on the internet is an e-commerce site so similar to the counter of a 250-square-foot bagel shop.
You can get all the classic types of bagels here, from cinnamon raisin to egg to plain to pumpernickel. Their stock rounds out a list of all the top New York-style options.
The prices are $1.25 to $1.30 for the bagel and less than $10 for shipping, a value that doesn't break the bank.
There’s nothing like a bagel shop that can play to a wide crowd of people. While New Yorker Bagel scores points for a great chew and crispness, they’re included on this list because they have 23 types of bagels available on offer through their delivery system, way more than any other service. You choose your dozen based on packs of three, so each dozen comes with four different types of bagels.
These 23 flavors are more than just the standards like poppy, sesame, and everything. The list is filled with inventive and out-there options like Cranberry Power, Marble Rye, Jalapeño Red Pepper, Kalamata Olive, and many more.
New Yorker Bagel wants you to get your bagels as fresh as possible, so they guarantee free overnight shipping via FedEx, which means that the total cost is $39.50 per dozen. This is pricey, but that's going straight to guaranteeing quality and freshness.
And when you get hooked on these bagels, you might as well join their Bagel of the Month club. It’s the same deal with the four options per dozen, and you can change those options from month to month. What better way to kick off a month than with a set of fresh, high-quality bagels?
What Is a Bagel Delivery Service?
A bagel delivery service delivers fresh bagels to the home, whether you desire New York-style, Montreal-style, or new varieties of bagels.
How Long Will Bagels From a Bagel Delivery Service Stay Fresh?
As bagels are fresh-baked and then shipped, New York Bagel suggests eating them within 15 hours of delivery and then freezing any remaining bagels to eat later.
How Much Does a Bagel Delivery Service Cost?
Costs depend on the bagel company, types of bagels ordered, and shipping costs. For example, Bagel Hole is one of the more affordable options at about $1.30 per bagel and less than $10 for shipping. The Bagel Nook has different prices for different bagels; and charges from $39 per dozen for tie-dye bagels and up to $79 per dozen for overloaded fruity pebbles bagels and cream cheese. New York Bagel ships overnight via FedEx, so their bagels cost $39.50 per dozen.
How We Chose the Best Bagel Delivery Services
We searched over 50 bagel shops and rated our favorites based on personal experience, user comments, press acclaim, and the useability of their delivery service.
There are a lot of great bagel shops that have made it possible for us to enjoy their bagels at home, but this list captures a wide variety of options, ranging from the best of the New York-style, Montreal-style, and where bagel making is headed in the future.
All of these options offer customers the highest quality as well, with quick shipping options ensuring freshness while remaining more-or-less affordable.
We didn't want just a standard list of solid options, so this roundup is dotted with out-there and creative bagel-makers who are pushing the boundaries of what's possible and delicious.