The 7 Best Brownie Delivery Services of 2020

Best Overall: Fat Witch Bakery

Sign Up Now

Everyone likes their brownies a little different: gooey, cakey, crispy, fluffy, stout. With Fat Witch Bakery, you don't have to choose. All options are available at your fingertips.

The company calls its brownies "Witches," and there are endless options. Original, Double Chocolate, and Caramel will basically cover your needs, but there’s a Blonde, Java, Breakfast, Red (cherry), Snow (white chocolate), minty Emerald City, and the nutty Walnut Witch.

Brownies even come in smaller sizes called Witch Babies, and Fat Witch will even send you Witch Ends—just the crispy edges of their brownies for people who don’t like the gooey, middle part. Finally, they will send you pre-packaged brownie mix and cookbooks so you can make your own at home.

When you're ready to make a purchase, just add your brownie type to the cart, and step through the dialog boxes on their website. They ship via major carriers, so if you’re really in a brownie pinch, you can get them overnighted from New York with next day delivery.

For around $3, you'll get a three-and-a-half-ounce brownie, while a Witch Baby is about $2. A brownie mix is roughly $6.

Each brownie comes individually wrapped, so you know they’ll stay fresh for up to a week (add two more weeks if in the fridge.) And the best part? You can rotate purchases from your cookie or cake deliveries.

Best Fudgy: The Killer Brownie Co.

Sign Up Now

The best sort of brownie overwhelms your sensations, making you weak in the knees. The French have a fantastic term for it—le petit mort—the little death, which is most appropriate for our most decadent entry, The Killer Brownie Co.

Founded 30 years ago at a local grocery store in Dayton, Ohio, The Killer Brownie Co. takes you right to the edge with its gooey, triple-layer brownies. Their original flavor isn’t even just chocolate: It’s chocolate, paired with a layer of buttery pecans, betwixt one of velvety caramel. That’s Killer Brownie just getting started.

Choose from flavors like Confetti, Cookies & Cream, Salted Caramel, German Chocolate, Raspberry, and more. There's even a brownie that’s a combination of two tri-layers in case you can't make your mind up on a flavor.

A four-pack costs $20, and a tray of 16 assorted brownie bites is $30. Flat-rate shipping is $13 for the lower 48 states, but there's an extra fee if you're located in Alaska or Hawaii.

Best Nostalgic: Mrs. Fields

Sign Up Now

While Mrs. Fields is originally known for its cookies, its brownies also became a sensation, defining the store-bought experience for as long as we can remember.

Try as you might to imitate the Mrs. Fields experience with any number of online recipes, you're better off just enjoying the real deal.

Mrs. Fields’ website is made for easy browsing, but you will only find options for their Brownie Bites. This may come as a disappointment to some, but others will take this as an opportunity to take tiny bites throughout the day and claim they never actually finished a whole brownie.

The Deluxe Signature Brownie Bite Tin is the company's brownie-only bundle option, and you'll spend roughly $60 for a pack of 144. With your decadent purchase, you'll get a tin, which you can use as a keepsake. Each half dozen is packaged individually for freshness, and you have 12 days of shelf life to tear through the entire lot.

Most Instagram-worthy: Zola Bakes

Sign Up Now

If you want to impress your followers with some mind-blowing brownies, order a batch of Zola Bakes rainbow cookie brownies and rack up the likes.

Zola Bakes founder Samantha Zola started making tri-layered, rainbow cookies with neon-colored sponge cake and then decided to put them inside brownies. The results? Splashes of rainbow-colored ecstasy surrounded by chocolate brownie morsels. It’s a marvel of the senses.

Zola Bakes takes the high-end culinary pastry training of Épicerie Boulud & Magnolia Bakery and makes it available via Goldbelly. Choose a six-pack for $35 that includes two raspberry rainbow brownies, two apricot rainbow brownies, and two Nutella rainbow brownies. There’s also a 12-pack for around $70 in which you'll get four of the aforementioned flavors.

You can expect your treats to be topped-off with rainbow-colored, candy-coated chocolate chips. The attention to detail is otherworldly.

Orders are shipped directly from the shop Monday through Thursday. If you live in Alaska or Hawaii and choose two-day shipping, you will need to pay an additional fee.

Best Boozy: Brownie Points

Sign Up Now

If you're ever torn between drinks or dessert, there's an option that lets you have both. With Ohio-based Brownie Points, you can enjoy a boozy, gooey pop of brownie fun.

And don’t worry about mixing liquors: There are options here for bourbon, wine, and tequila drinkers, with flavors like Boozy Bourbon Pecan Praline, Brown Butter Bourbon, Spiked Salted Caramel Bourbon, Cabernet Chocolate Fudge, Plastered Pina Colada, and Tipsy Key Lime Margarita. This is in addition to a full slate of brownies from Original Chocolate to Gourmet Buckeye.

Boozy brownies retail at around $2 each, but there are four delivery options to choose from: a six-pack for around $38, a 12-pack for roughly $53, a 24-pack for approximately $84, and a "Party Time" assortment box for about $87.

You can choose a delivery date if you're gifting a box to a friend, and during the warm weather, you will need to pay an additional fee for a cooler and ice pack.

Best for Gifts: Fairytale Brownies

Sign Up Now

Fairytale Brownies are indeed magical. The company's claim to fame is the legendary Callebaut Belgian dark chocolate it uses in all of its brownies.

The brownies themselves come in three delicious sizes: Full-Size Brownies, Snack-Size Sprites, and Bite-Size Morsels, likely so you can sprinkle them like fairy dust around your house.

When you're ready to start an order, there are several delivery options to choose from. Bite-Size Morsel bundles start at around $30 for 12 brownies and go up to about $64 for 48 of them. Snack-Size Sprite packages begin at around $28 for eight and go up to about $96 for 48 treats.

Finally, Full-Size Brownie deliveries start at roughly $34 for six and go up to two dozen for about $91. It's also worth taking a look at their gift boxes, which double as photo frames.

Standard shipping is free throughout the U.S.