The 10 Best Carbon Steel Pans of 2021

Light and naturally non-stick, these pans are a great replacement for cast iron

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks
"Like Lodge's well-known cast iron cookware, this carbon steel skillet is pre-seasoned, so you can start cooking right away."
"Well constructed with an ergonomic handle, this pan is easy to maneuver and extremely well-priced for the quality."
"Just dipping your toe into carbon steel? This affordable option is a good starter piece that comes ready-to-use."
"Perfect for quick stir-frying, this deep frying pan will need to be seasoned when it arrives at your door."
"There's a reason carbon steel is a classic material for paella pans. This one will help you get the perfect socarrat every time."
"Crafted from a single piece of steel, this pan is built to last for generations, but is preseasoned so there's no break-in period."
"Not just for crepes, this flat pan can also be used to sear meat, fry eggs, make flatbread, and more."
"The sloped sides make it easy to flip food in the pan, and the arched handle offers a firm, balanced grip."
"This grill pan offers enough space for steaks, chops, or burgers and creates impressive grill marks on the food."
"Sauté pans are similar to frying pans, but while the sides on frying pans are flared, the sides of sauté pans are more vertical."

Cast iron pans have been a popular kitchen staple for years, but professional chefs around the world have come to love pans of a different material: carbon steel. This alloy is made from steel and carbon (just like cast iron) but in slightly different proportions. When used to create cookware, the result is a lighter, less brittle, smoother metal that performs almost exactly like cast iron, with similar durability and versatility. Once the pan has been seasoned, it will give you a nonstick surface that stands up to metal cooking tools, so you won’t have to worry about scratches. You’ll be able to use a carbon steel pan for searing, frying, sauteing, and broiling on just about any cooktop, including induction, BBQ grills, and on a campfire.  

Like cast iron, carbon steel does require some mindful maintenance in order to retain its seasoning, but when it's properly cared for, it will last for the long-term. If you’re thinking about investing in some new cookware, here are the best carbon steel pans.

Best Overall: Lodge Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet

Lodge Seasoned Steel Skillet
What We Like
  • Arrives pre-seasoned

  • Securely riveted handles

  • Can use on any cooktop

  • Inexpensive

What We Don't Like
  • Hand wash only

  • Requires special attention to maintain seasoning

Lodge is well-known for its vast array of cast iron cookware, so it makes sense that the company would venture into making carbon steel cookware as well. Like Lodge's cast iron, this skillet comes pre-seasoned, so you can start cooking with it right away, but of course, more seasoning will make it more nonstick and more rust-resistant. The skillet comes in sizes ranging from 8-inch to 15-inch and is also broiler safe.

Like cast iron, carbon steel pans become more and more nonstick over time, without the need for special coatings during manufacturing. In use, carbon steel pans are thinner and lighter than cast iron, and also more responsive to temperature changes. This one can be used on all cooktops, including induction, as well as on a barbecue grill or campfire. 

Runner Up, Best Overall: Matfer Bourgeat Black Steel Round Fry Pan

What We Like
  • Professional-grade quality

  • Suitable for all cooktops

  • Welded handle makes it easy to clean

What We Don't Like
  • Will require seasoning and regular maintenance to upkeep surface

This all-purpose pan by Matfer Bourgeat is made in France and is designed for commercial and home use. Constructed of unseasoned black carbon steel, you’ll have to season it yourself (but once you do, it will perform as a non-stick surface). The steel handle is welded securely to the body of the pan, and since it does not have traditional rivets, it is easier to keep clean since there’s nowhere for food particles and residue to hide.

The angled sides make it suitable for a variety of uses, from stir-frying to sauteeing, and you’ll be able to use this on just about any cooking surface, even induction. Be sure to wash the pan thoroughly with a bristle brush and mild dish detergent to remove the protective coating before first use.

Best Budget: BK Cookware 12-Inch Black Carbon Steel Skillet

BK 10 Inch Black Steel Skillet
What We Like
  • Arrives pre-seasoned

  • Inexpensive

  • Oven safe to 600 degrees

What We Don't Like
  • Not as durable as higher end pans

If you’re not sure you’ll love cooking with carbon steel, this affordable 12-inch skillet is a good starter piece. It’s pre-seasoned, so you can use it right after giving it a preliminary wash to remove the protective silicone wax and it’s a nice size for searing a few small chops for dinner. The handle is coated cast iron, and shaped to give you a comfortable hand-hold while you cook.

Best with High Sides: De Buyer Mineral "B" 12.5-Inch Steel Fry Pan

de Buyer Mineral "B" Fry Pan
What We Like
  • Beautifully constructed

  • High sides gives it versatility

  • Ergonomic handle has good grip and balance

What We Don't Like
  • Oven safe maximum temperature is lower than some other pans

This pan straddles the line between a low-sided frying pan and a wok, with medium-high sides that will keep your food contained when you’re stir-frying, yet it won’t take as much storage space as a wok. This pick is made in France and comes with a beeswax coating that protects the metal as the pan travels from the manufacturer to your door.

The pan has a long, ergonomic handle that is securely riveted to the pan's body, to help you toss the ingredients as you cook and easily hang the pan when it's not in use. You can also use this pan in the oven for a maximum of 20 minutes at 400 degrees.

Best Paella Pan: Magefesa Carbon Steel Paella Pan

Magefesa Carbon Steel Paella Pan
What We Like
  • Well-built, traditional style

  • Generous handles make it easy to move on and off the burner

  • Comes in a wide variety of sizes to accommodate any size party

What We Don't Like
  • Can be difficult to store

  • Hand wash only

If you’re going to buy a paella pan, why not buy one from a Spanish cookware company like Magfesa? They’ve got the know-how and the experience to make a pan that will perform when you need it. Paella pans are often made from carbon steel, which helps to produce the socarrat—the crisp rice at the bottom of the pan—while the dimpled bottom on this pan also improves the cooking process.

Two generous handles make this one easy to move and carry as it goes from stovetop to oven to table. This option is available in a variety of sizes so you can scale your recipe to however many people you're serving.

Best Splurge: SOLIDTEKNICS AUS-ION Non-Stick Skillet

AUS ION 13 Non-Stick Skillet
What We Like
  • Super sturdy single-piece construction

  • Arrives pre-seasoned

  • Helper handle makes moving this pan easy

What We Don't Like
  • Expensive

Made from a single piece of Australian steel and designed to be a pan that gets passed down through generations, this skillet is pre-seasoned so you can get right to cooking, whether you’re searing steaks or cooking the perfect burger. The long handle has cutouts near the pan’s edge to help vent heat and keep the handle cooler in use, while a helper handle gives you an extra hand-hold when you’ve got a full pan to move.

Best Crepe Pan: deBuyer Mineral 'B' Carbon Steel Crepe Pan

What We Like
  • Solid construction

  • Securely riveted handles

  • Works great for omelettes and pancakes as well as crepes

What We Don't Like
  • Protective beeswax coating can be challenging to remove

  • Hand wash only

Made in France by a well-known, premium cookware company, this crepe pan comes with a protective beeswax coating that should be removed before seasoning the pan. Once it is seasoned, it provides a beautifully nonstick surface and even heating to make crepes, pancakes, and omelets with minimal oil.

While this pan has low sides that make it perfect for crepes, it can also be used for searing meat, making or heating tortillas, and cooking any foods that don’t require the higher sides of a traditional skillet or frying pan.

Best Frying Pan: Made In Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan

Blue Carbon Steel Frying Pan
What We Like
  • Super-slick surface

  • Becomes more nonstick over time

  • Works on any cooking surface

What We Don't Like
  • Seasoning can be spotty

  • Not dishwasher safe

  • Needs seasoning before use

The Made In company is making a name for itself with quality kitchen gear, so it’s no surprise that its blue carbon steel frying pan is a favorite. While the blue color is distinctive when the pan arrives, it darkens with additional seasoning and with more use, as it should. The sloped sides make it easy to flip food in the pan, and the arched handle offers a firm, balanced grip. A hanging hole on the handle makes it easy to hang the pan on a hook to keep it at hand. This pan is available in three sizes, and it can be personalized with up to 24 letters and spaces on the handle for a great gift or just a personal touch for the kitchen.

Best Grill Pan: Denmark Tools 10.5-inch Heavy Duty Grill Pan

What We Like
  • Arrives pre-seasoned

  • Oven-safe

  • Large area for cooking steaks, chops, or burgers

What We Don't Like
  • Not dishwasher friendly

Now that carbon steel pans are making inroads in home kitchens, companies are making more types of pans besides the original frying pans. This 10 1/2-inch grill pan offers enough space for steaks, chops, or burgers and creates impressive grill marks on the food. Not just for meats, this is also perfect for grilling asparagus and other vegetables, and it’s oven-safe so food can start on the stove and finish in the oven. This pan is pre-seasoned, so it’s ready for cooking when it arrives, but it gets even better with more use or additional seasoning. The handle is secured with two rivets and has a hole at the end for hanging on a hook.

Best Sauté Pan: Northwest Skillet Company Carbon Steel Sauté Pans

What We Like
  • Handmade in Oregon

  • Easy to hang or display

  • Naturally nonstick with no chemical coating

What We Don't Like
  • Expensive

Sauté pans are very similar to frying pans, but while the sides on frying pans are flared, the sides of sauté pans are more vertical. This can make it easier to get under foods with a spatula since the straight sides act as a bumper. The straight sides also offer more cooking space at the bottom of the pan. These pans are made by hand in Oregon, so each is an individual piece of hand-crafted, functional art.

To make the pans just a bit more special, they are available with a choice of three artistically designed handles, each triple-riveted for security and each with a hanging hole at the end so they can be proudly displayed in the kitchen. The sauté pans are available in 8-inch and 10-inch sizes. 

Final Verdict

The Lodge 12-Inch Seasoned Carbon Steel Skillet takes the top spot because of its lightweight yet rugged construction and how quickly it heats up. Plus, it's easy to clean. On a budget? Give the BK Cookware 11-Inch Black Carbon Steel Skillet a try. It's nonstick out of the box and lighter than a typical cast iron pan.

Why Trust The Spruce Eats?

Donna Currie is a food writer and product tester for The Spruce Eats. A self-professed "kitchen geek," she's written many roundups on a range of essential kitchen items, from the best induction burners to the top seafood kitchen tools of the year.

This piece was edited by Bernadette Machard de Gramont, an LA-based writer who specializes in global food and wine content. She researches and tests a variety of cookware, bakeware, and wine tools, and interviews field experts for their insight.

Continue to 5 of 10 below.
Continue to 9 of 10 below.