We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.
Nothing beats a slice of rich and creamy cheesecake. But the attempts to bake a cheesecake can be an event. From making sure the cream cheese is warm enough, so the batter isn’t lumpy, to baking it in a hot water bath so it doesn’t crack, to storing it overnight in the fridge to firm up, cheesecake is not an instant gratification baking project.
Thankfully, there are great cheesecake delivery services that will bring you a silky smooth and decadent cheesecake right to your front door without all that effort. We’ve searched all over the Internet to find you the best cheesecake delivery services. Here are our top picks.
Best Cheesecake Delivery Services of 2023
- Best Overall: Harry & David
- Best Marketplace: Goldbelly
- Best Cheesecake Sandwich: Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches
- Best for Birthdays: Chico's Cheesecakes
- Best for Hippies: High Society Cheesecake
Best Overall : Harry & David
:fill(white):max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Harry_and_David-a8fdfb50362648619574dd940f1b1cf3.jpg)
Harry & David
- Price: $39.99 + $13.99 shipping
- Est. Shipping Time: 4-7 days shipping
- Availability: Monday through Wednesday
Harry & David offers over a dozen cheesecake flavors. However, the deliciousness of the Original Cheesecake Factory cheesecake, is what makes it the best overall pick.
You can order the original Cheesecake Factory cheesecake
Reasonably priced
Free upgrade to express shipping on select items
Can only order Monday through Wednesday morning
For quality, selection, and value, it's tough to beat Harry & David. The company has partnered with The Cheesecake Factory, one of the world’s top cheesecake producers whose desserts are popular for a reason.
Harry & David carries more than a dozen cakes from The Cheesecake Factory, from the Original Cheesecake and Chocolate Mousse Cheesecake to cake-and-cheesecake layer cakes, such as Reese's peanut butter chocolate cheesecake. No matter the occasion, you're sure to find a cheesecake to fit the bill. No one is disappointed to receive a Cheesecake Factory cheesecake.
Harry & David ships to all 50 states and a selection of international destinations. Save on shipping with the company's "celebrations passport" program. Membership costs around $30 per year.
Best Marketplace : Goldbelly
:fill(white):max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Goldbelly-1fa62665a8554b2683848acbdb839612.jpg)
Goldbelly
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T&C applies.
- Price: Starting at $32 + shipping which varies
- Est. Shipping Time: 1 to 5 days
- Availability: 7 days a week
Goldbelly online marketplace offers cheesecakes from more than 15 different establishments, including institutions such as Junior’s Cheesecake in New York, Eli’s Cheesecake Company in Chicago, and The Pie Hole in Los Angeles.
Wide variety of cheesecakes from establishments
Often times free shipping
Variety of sizes from individual to extra large
Wide number of choices can be overwhelming
Different vendors have different prices and shipping rates & times
While Harry & David have The Cheesecake Factory, Goldbelly has just about everyone else: Junior's, Eli's, The Nuns of New Skete, and many more.
Goldbelly's online marketplace offers a wide selection of cheesecake flavors and formats. Take a look at the Gooey Butter Cheesecake from Blue Owl Bakery, the New York from the Nuns of New Skete, the Cheesecake Dippers from Eli's, and the Cheesecake Macarons from Kreuther Handcrafted Chocolate. And that's just a handful of highlights.
Goldbelly has at least five dozen different cheesecakes from more than 15 establishments. It's a wondrous cheesecake bazaar focused on curation, so you know that all the products it carries are beloved.
There are several different products, so costs vary widely. Expect to spend around $65. Many items come with free shipping, and Goldbelly ships nationwide.
Best Cheesecake Sandwich : Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches
:fill(white):max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Grandmas_Cheesecake_Sandwiches-f63aff698cb2440992bce3ec2a48f119.jpg)
Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches
- Price: $79 + free shipping
- Est. Shipping Time: 2 days
- Availability: Monday through Wednesday
Riffing on the idea of an ice cream sandwich, Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches come in a variety of creamy cheesecake flavors, all nestled between two soft-baked cookie wafers.
Unique cheesecake sandwich
Can be eaten frozen or chilled
Multiple flavor options
Only available as a sandwich, not a traditional cheesecake
Individually handmade, so sandwiches can be inconsistent in size
Expensive
Growing up, Lisa Cotoggio was inspired by her grandmother Raphaella's signature cheesecakes. Years later, Lisa founded a business to share Raphaella's legacy with the world and added her own unique twist. That's how the cheesecake sandwich was born.
Raphaella has since passed away, but her cheesecakes live on at Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches.
Grandma's makes more than 20 flavors of Cheesecake Sandwiches, including blueberry, butterscotch, chocolate eclair, salted caramel, and rainbow cookie crumble. Each sandwich is handcrafted, so no two are exactly the same.
You must order a minimum of eight sandwiches, and each one costs about $10. Grandma's ships the sandwiches frozen and packed in dry ice via FedEx overnight, which is pricey—but worth it when they arrive.
Store them for up to a year in the freezer or seven to 10 days in the refrigerator.
Best for Birthdays : Chico's Cheesecakes
:fill(white):max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/Chicos-4c08e400bfaf46c6a3578f71937c266e.jpg)
Chico's Cheesecakes
- $30 + additional fee for shipping
- Est. Shipping Time: Up to 1 week
- Availability: Not available online
Chico’s Cheesecakes is automatically Instagram fodder with its unicorn birthday cake cheesecake, but its other options such as cheesecake jars, cheesecake cupcakes, and cheesecakes in pie tins are equally appealing.
Unicorn birthday cake cheesecake is whimsical and eye catching
Fun cheesecake in jar options
Lots of cheesecake flavors
Full sized cheesecakes are in pie tins not straight-sided
Cheesecakes look more homestyle baked
Chico's Cheesecakes is a family business with a family recipe. In this family, it seems the love language is cheesecake.
Located in Cincinnati, Ohio, Chico's Cheesecakes is named in honor of the founder's grandfather, Maurice "Chico" Harrell. Chico's jar cheesecakes are spectacular. Take a look at the Unicorn Birthday Cake Cheesecake, and you'll understand why. Indeed, any person celebrating and receiving this cheesecake will feel loved, honored, and appreciated.
Besides the Unicorn, Chico's offers many flavors of jars, cheesecake cupcakes, and specialty cheesecakes. Chico's more unique flavors include Caramel Pecan, Raspberry Oreo, and Apple Pie Crumble.
The brand does things a little differently when it comes to its full-size cheesecakes, baking them in pie tins instead of the standard, straight-sided springform pans. The edges aren't perpendicular to most cheesecakes; they look more like a slice of pie.
The 9-inch is roughly $30, and the 10-inch is about $35, plus shipping. You can also get cheesecake in a jar for $7 (4 ounces) or $12 for an 8-ounce jar. A 1-pound loaf of cheesecake runs about $15. Chico's ships locally, and the cost is calculated at checkout, based on your location.
Best for Hippies : High Society Cheesecake
:fill(white):max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/hsc-logo-5e62309066324eb49080eb82445d90ba.jpg)
High Society Cheesecake
- Price: $49.99 + $35 shipping
- Up to 1 week
- Availability: Mondays
High Society has a number of delightful cheesecake flavors but their tie-dye cheesecake, an orange and honey colorful concoction is the ideal cheesecake for the hippie, deadhead or flower child.
Tie-dye cheesecake is visually stunning
Wide selection of flavors
Sampler cheesecakes and mini cheesecakes options
Not shipped by the slice; mini cake and whole cake only
Only ships on Mondays
Shipping is expensive
Founded in 2006, High Society Cheesecake came from founder Marcus Morris' work spent perfecting his cheesecake recipe for nearly two years. With his Nebraska-based business, Morris's efforts have since been rewarded with reliable customer reviews and distribution through many local markets.
High Society Cheesecake has a stunning selection, but its Tie Dye cheesecake is truly a work of art. Whether you want to remind the aging hippie in your life of their flower child days or wow your friends at your next croquet garden party, the Tie Dye cheesecake (for around $50) will be a beautiful addition. We just couldn't leave this cheesecake off the list.
Like Chico's Unicorn Birthday Cheesecake, we've never seen anything quite like it. Rainbow-colored and flavored with orange and honey, every bite is like frolicking through a Peter Max painting. If the Tie Dye cheesecake isn't right for you, there are more standard flavors such as Turtle, Oreo, and Coconut Cream.
Whole cheesecakes from High Society are nine inches in diameter and about 2.5 inches tall. Shipping costs are about $35 for all cheesecakes. They also offer a pack of 16 assorted mini cheesecakes if you want to try all the varieties—High Society Cheesecake ships nationwide, but only on Mondays.
Final Verdict
Creamy, smooth and rich cheesecakes can be a hassle to bake. But thankfully there are plenty of delivery services that will send you the perfect cheesecake for every occasion. There are even various different versions of cheesecakes that can be delivered, such as small mini cheesecakes, cheesecake sandwiches, cheesecakes in a jar, as well as whole cheesecakes and sampler cheesecakes with different sliced flavors. We picked Harry and David as the best cheesecake delivery service because of its reasonable prices, and its variety: the company sells original Cheesecake Factory cheesecakes, as well as several different flavors of its own cheesecake.
Compare the Best Cheesecake Delivery Services
Company | Price (+Shipping) | Estimated Shipping Time | Availability | Gift Options |
---|---|---|---|---|
Harry & David Best Overall | $39.99 + $13.99 shipping | 4-7 days shipping | Monday through Wednesday | Yes |
Goldbelly Best Marketplace | Starting at $32 + various shipping fees | 1 to 5 days | 7 days a week | Yes |
Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches Best Cheesecake Sandwich | $79 + free shipping | 2 days | Monday through Wednesday | Yes |
Chico's Cheesecakes Best for Birthdays | $30 + additional fee for shipping | Up to 1 week | Not available online | No |
High Society Cheesecake Best for Hippies | $49.99 + $35 shipping | Up to 1 week | Mondays | No |
What Is a Cheesecake Delivery Service?
A cheesecake delivery service ships cheesecake to the home. They are generally shipped frozen and can be defrosted when ready to enjoy. The majority of the cheesecake delivery services provide one-time orders versus requiring an ongoing subscription.
How Much Does a Cheesecake Delivery Service Cost?
Prices vary and range from $30 at Chico’s Cheesecakes and $35 at Harry & David, up to $65 per cheesecake at Goldbelly. It's worth mentioning that shipping may cost more than usual, but that's to ensure the cheesecake retains its texture and freshness while in transit.
Can I Order Cheesecake by the Slice From a Cheesecake Delivery Service?
While most cheesecake delivery services don’t ship individual slices, some, such as Harry & David, sell a Cheesecake Party Wheel with four different flavors. Or for smaller size cheesecakes, Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches are individual portions you can order in various flavors.
Methodology
We researched and looked at numerous articles, lists, and reviews all over the Internet to find the best cheesecake delivery service. With so many options, we had a hard time narrowing it down. The companies that made this list offer the widest and most interesting selection of cheesecake flavors, had the best reviews, and offered the highest quality and varied styles of cheesecake products. Website navigation and ease of ordering was important, too.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-1207948426-978818a9ad3843a4871d919f63e08987.jpg)
Arx0nt / Getty Images