Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: Harry & David
For quality, selection, and value, it's tough to beat Harry & David. You can get its well-reviewed signature New York-style cheesecake for about $30, plus a modest shipping charge—a very competitive price.
If that was the whole story, it wouldn’t be enough to earn the Best Overall title. But Harry & David has a secret weapon: In addition to its in-house offerings, it has partnered with The Cheesecake Factory, one of the world’s top cheesecake producers. There's no guesswork here: These cheesecakes are popular for a reason.
Harry & David carries more than a dozen cakes from The Cheesecake Factory, from its towering New York-style and Banana Cream to Oreo Dream Extreme. Most cheesecakes are full-size, but there are also cheesecake cupcakes and pops. No matter the occasion, you're sure to find a cheesecake to fit the bill. No one is disappointed to receive a Cheesecake Factory cheesecake. The bottom line: These two popular and time-tested brands are sure to deliver the goods.
Harry & David ships to all 50 states and a selection of international destinations. Save on shipping with the company's "celebrations passport" program. Membership costs around $30 per year. Join, and you'll get free shipping on eligible items, which includes all cheesecakes and hundreds of other items across all the brands under Harry & David's umbrella.
Best Variety: Simply Gourmand
Located in Dryden, Michigan, Simply Gourmand offers 100 different flavors of cheesecake.
You can order cheesecake in almost every conceivable format, including full-size cakes, mini cakes, jars, push-up pops, and cheesecake-filled macarons. Simply Gourmand will even make a cheesecake for your wedding (shipping it is probably another story, however).
Simply Gourmand makes every cheesecake to order, and all of them can be made gluten-free. Select the gluten-free crust when ordering. There are also a few vegan options. The complete list of flavors is too long to include here, but some of the standouts include Maple Bourbon Pecan, Death by Chocolate, Cabernet Blackberry Blueberry, and Rumchata Cannoli. If there's a flavor you are craving, odds are Simply Gourmand has it—though not all flavors are available in all sizes.
All cheesecakes are shipped frozen in recyclable packaging with reusable ice packs. Simply Gourmand ships via USPS Priority Mail, Monday to Wednesday only. Prices range from about $5 to $45, plus shipping, depending on the size of the required flat rate box.
Best Value: Bassano's
Bada bing, bada boom, we love Bassano’s attitude. These New York Italians may have defected to Florida, but the sunshine hasn’t softened their in-your-face inclinations. Bassano claims its cheesecake is second best in the world "cause you don't disrespect your Mother, capisce!"
The website openly takes a swipe at Junior's, the well known Brooklyn cheesecake bakery, calling it out for being past its prime and referencing the Gotye song "Somebody That I Used To Know." Ouch! All this braggadocio, however, can’t hide this family bakery’s sweet, soft heart.
Bassano’s supports a different charity every month, and, best of all, it offers free shipping on all of its cheesecakes—an amazing deal, given the fact that each cheesecake weighs between 4. 5 and 8 pounds, measures 9 inches in diameter, and is 3 inches high.
Bassano’s carries many flavors, both regular and slightly outrageous. Highlights include Claudio's Cannoli Cheesecake, Pistachio cheesecake, and Cherry Blossom.
Bassano's ships on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, and prices vary. Many cheesecakes cost around $46, but some, such as Claudio's Cannoli, are more expensive. Shipping is free anywhere in the United States.
Best Marketplace: Goldbelly
While Harry & David has The Cheesecake Factory, Goldbelly has just about everyone else: Junior's, Eli's, The Nuns of New Skete, and many more.
Goldbelly’s online marketplace offers a wide selection of cheesecake flavors and formats. Take a look at the Gooey Butter Cheesecake from Blue Owl, the New York from the Nuns of New Skete, the Cheesecake Dippers from Eli's, and the Cheesecake Macarons from Kreuther Handcrafted Chocolate. And that's just a handful of highlights.
Goldbelly has at least five dozen different cheesecakes from more than 15 establishments. It's a wondrous cheesecake bazaar, focused on curation, so you know that all the products it carries are beloved.
There are several different products, so costs vary widely. Expect to spend around $65. Many items come with free shipping, and Goldbelly ships nationwide.
Best Cheesecake Sandwich: Grandma's Cheesecake Sandwiches
Growing up, Lisa Cotoggio was inspired by her grandmother Raphaella’s signature cheesecakes. Years later, Lisa founded a business to share Raphaella’s legacy with the world, and added her own special twist. That’s how the cheesecake sandwich was born.
Alas, Raphaella has passed away, but her cheesecakes live on at Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches. When it opened in 2019, Grandma’s sold out of everything on each of their first three days of operation.
Grandma’s makes over 20 flavors of Cheesecake Sandwiches, including blueberry, butterscotch, chocolate eclair, salted caramel, and rainbow cookie crumble. If you dare, you can also look at the nutrition information on the website. Each sandwich is handcrafted, so no two are exactly the same.
You must order a minimum of six sandwiches, and each one costs about $5. Grandma's ships the sandwiches frozen and packed in dry ice via FedEx overnight, which is pricey— but worth it when they arrive.
Store them for up to a year in the freezer, or for seven to 10 days in the refrigerator.
Best for Birthdays: Chico's Cheesecakes
Chico's Cheesecakes is a family business with a family recipe. In this family, it seems, the love language is cheesecake.
Located in Cincinnati, Ohio, Chico's Cheesecakes is named in honor of the founder's grandfather, Maurice "Chico" Harrell. Chico’s jar cheesecakes are spectacular, but take a look at the Unicorn Birthday Cake Cheesecake and you’ll understand our decision. Surely, any person celebrating and receiving this cheesecake will feel loved, honored, and appreciated.
Besides the Unicorn, Chico's has many flavors of jars, cheesecake cupcakes, and specialty cheesecakes. Some of Chico's more unique flavors include Caramel Pecan, Raspberry Oreo, and Banana Pudding.
The brand does things a little differently when it comes to its full-size cheesecakes, baking them in pie tins instead of the standard, straight-sided springform pans. The edges aren't perpendicular the way most cheesecakes are; they look more like a slice of pie.
Jars come in 4 or 8 ounces. Specialty cheesecakes come in medium and large sizes, with no word on precise measurements. The medium is roughly $30, and the large is about $35, plus shipping. Chico's ships via UPS, and the cost is calculated at checkout, based on your location.
Best for Hippies: High Society Cheesecake
Founded in 2006, High Society Cheesecake came from founder Marcus Morris' work spent perfecting his cheesecake recipe for two years. With his Nebraska-based business, Morris' efforts have since been rewarded with solid customer reviews and distribution through many local markets.
High Society Cheesecake has a handsome selection, but its Tie Dye cheesecake is truly a work of art. Whether you want to remind the aging hippie in your life of their flower child days or wow your friends at your next croquet garden party, the Tie Dye cheesecake (for around $40) will be a beautiful addition. We just couldn't leave this cheesecake off the list.
Like Chico's Unicorn Birthday Cheesecake, we've never seen anything quite like it: Rainbow-colored and flavored with orange and honey, every bite is like frolicking through a Peter Max painting. If the Tie Dye cheesecake isn't right for you, there are more standard, conformist flavors like Twix, Oreo, and Coconut Cream.
Whole cheesecakes from High Society are 9 inches in diameter and about 2.5 inches tall. Shipping costs are about $35 for all cheesecakes. They also offer a pack of 25 assorted mini cheesecakes if you want to try all the varieties. High Society Cheesecake ships nationwide, but only on Mondays.
How We Chose the Best Cheesecake Delivery Services
There’s no shortage of cheesecake in this world, and we looked at more than 60 different websites. Our choices came down to two things: unique cheesecakes and great reviews. Every company on this list has both.
From big corporate brands like Harry & David's partnership with The Cheesecake Factory to mom-and-pop shops like Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches, each and every one of the bakers we chose brings something special to the marketplace.
Because cakes are necessary for birthdays, we chose Chico's Cheesecakes as the top pick for that category because of its go-to family recipe. We also wanted to make sure that readers knew where to get the most bang for their buck when it came to cheesecakes, so we handpicked Bassano's for its overall value, comparing cheesecake price and size.