The Best Cookie Jars for Keeping Baked Goods Fresh and Accessible

Our top pick is the Oxo Good Grips Pop Cookie Jar

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Commerce Photo Composite

The Spruce Eats / Sabrina Jiang

Cookie jars are a staple in any baker’s or dessert lover’s kitchen. They can serve as storage and décor all while keeping cookies fresher for longer. Whether you’ve just baked a fresh batch of chocolate chip cookies or are looking for an aesthetically pleasing and easy-access option for housing Oreos, a good cookie jar is a must-have item.

The Spruce Eats Top Picks

At the top of our list is Oxo’s Good Grips 3-Quart Pop Medium Cookie Jar. The lid seals and unseals with the simple press of a button, and the jar itself is optimized to save space on your counter or in your pantry. Style Setter’s Chalkboard Glass Canister Set is a great choice for anyone on a budget. It comes with three labeled canisters at an affordable price.

From tall ceramic jars to ornate glass canisters, here are the best cookie jars. 

Best Overall: Oxo Good Grips 3-Quart Pop Medium Cookie Jar

4.7
Oxo Good Grip Pop Cookie Jar

Oxo

What We Like
  • Airtight seal

  • Angled opening for easy access

  • Multiple sizes available

What We Don't Like
  • Hand wash only

Who else recommends it? Delish also picked the Oxo Good Grips 3-Quart Pop Medium Cookie Jar.

What do buyers say? 86% of 5,600+ Amazon reviewers rated this product 5 stars.

Wouldn’t it be awesome if you could get a cookie with the press of a button? This 3-quart option from Oxo makes that dream come true—the airtight lid opens with ease once you press the center button. The pop lid isn’t the only convenient feature, though. There are anti-slip grips on the bottom of the jar, so it won’t slide around. Additionally, the back and sides of the jar are flattened, so you can save counter space. Oxo offers this jar in a large 5-quart size, as well. No matter what you put inside, it will stay fresh and easy to access. 

Material: Plastic, silicone | Capacity: 3 quarts | Weight: 15 ounces

Best Budget: Style Setter Chalkboard Glass Canister Set

Style Setter Chalkboard Canister Set

Amazon

What We Like
  • Chalkboard labels

  • Airtight seals

  • Beautiful, embossed glass

What We Don't Like
  • Hand wash only

  • Chalk is difficult to fully erase

We all love a good deal, and this glass canister set offers just that. For an affordable price, you get three glass jars—each a different size—complete with airtight lids and chalkboard labels. The glass itself has a vintage, embossed look and will fit in with most kitchen decors. You could fill one with cookies, one with candy, and another with cereal or nuts. Whatever you put inside, you can clearly mark it with a bit of chalk. 

Material: Glass | Capacity: 33, 44, 60 ounces | Weight: 5.35 pounds total

Best Stoneware: West Elm Utility Stoneware Cookie Jar

West Elm Utility Kitchen Stoneware Cookie Jar

West Elm

What We Like
  • Minimalist aesthetic

  • Airtight seal

  • Matching storage set available

What We Don't Like
  • Hand wash only

If you prefer a minimalist touch to your kitchen, this white stoneware cookie jar may interest you. Its tall cylindrical shape can save you counter space while holding tasty cookies, and the rubber ring helps seal the jar to keep your treats fresh for longer. You can buy any of the pieces in this West Elm set individually or as a six-piece collection. Each jar is clearly labeled and makes for a pleasing organizational addition to any kitchen.  

Material: Stoneware | Capacity: 170 ounces | Dimensions: 6.9 x 10.6 inches

Best Glass: Anchor Hocking 1-Gallon Heritage Hill Jar

Anchor Hocking Heritage 1-Gallon Glass Jar

Walmart

What We Like
  • Large capacity

  • Wide mouth

  • Dishwasher safe

What We Don't Like
  • Heavy

  • No seal

Glass is a very popular material for storing cookies. Not only does it look classic, but it’s also easy to see the treats inside. Anchor Hocking has a large-capacity 1-gallon glass jar that can hold enough cookies for a whole family. The big knob on top of the lid makes it easy to lift and keep a good grip on it, while the wide mouth offers easy cookie-grabbing access. If you want to store dry ingredients, like flour or sugar, there’s plenty of space to scoop. 

Material: Glass | Capacity: 1 gallon | Dimensions: 9.54 x 7 inches

Best Vintage-Style: The Pioneer Woman Adeline Cookie Jar

The Pioneer Woman Adeline Cookie Jar

Walmart

What We Like
  • Beautiful appearance

  • Silicone seal

What We Don't Like
  • Hard to see through opaque glass

  • Hand wash only

The term “cookie jar” often evokes fond memories of the past. If you’re someone who loves a vintage aesthetic, this cookie jar from Pioneer Woman would make a perfect addition to your home. It’s beautifully decorated with a ribbed pattern and round flowers. There are two color options available: clear glass and a gorgeous turquoise. Not only will this cookie jar hold your treats, but it can also serve as a stunning centerpiece.  

Material: Pressed glass | Dimensions: 9.45 x 12.60 x 9.50 inches

Best Animal-Shaped: At Home Ceramic Owl Cookie Jar

At Home Ceramic Owl Cookie Jar

At Home

What We Like
  • Adorable

  • White ceramic will match most decor

What We Don't Like
  • A bit heavy

This ceramic owl cookie jar certainly puts a spin on the classic children’s song, “Who stole the cookie from the cookie jar?” The beautiful jar has a number of owlish details from the feathers to the wide eyes to the stabilizing feet. It has a clean white ceramic finish with a few vintage-style touches along the edges. This jar is a great way to add a subtle, yet adorable decoration to your kitchen. 

Material: Ceramic | Weight: 3.1 pounds | Dimensions: 7.4 x 10.5 x 6.8 inches

Best Personalized: Personalization Mall Laurel Wreath Personalized Cookie Jar

Personalization Mall Laurel Wreath Personalized Cookie Jar

Personalization Mall

What We Like
  • Custom lettering and colors

  • Airtight lid

  • Dishwasher safe

What We Don't Like
  • Pricey

Cookie jars bring back a lot of memories, such as sneaking sweets as a kid or baking in the kitchen with grandma. A good cookie jar can hold a special place in our hearts, and this one allows you to customize your own with names, initials, and even short phrases. Choose from nine different colors, submit your custom lettering, and soon you’ll have a one-of-a-kind stoneware cookie jar. 

Material: Ceramic | Dimensions: 10.5 x 6.5 inches

Best Character: Underground Toys Star Wars R2-D2 Talking Cookie Jar

Underground Toys Star Wars R2D2 Talking Cookie Jar

Amazon

What We Like
  • Iconic R2-D2 sounds

  • Batteries included

  • Officially licensed

What We Don't Like
  • A bit small

  • Tricky to clean

This is the droid you’re looking for. Any fan of “Star Wars” would love this adorable cookie jar. Not only does it look just like everyone’s favorite astromech droid, but the jar also makes classic R2-D2 sounds when opened. R2 will guard any treats you store inside him as fiercely as he protected the Death Star plans for the rebels. There are countless character-themed cookie jars out there, but this one goes above and beyond in its loyal recreation and the memorable sound effects. Grab a glass of Aunt Beru’s blue milk and enjoy some cookies. 

Material: Plastic | Weight: 1.43 pounds | Dimensions: 9.06 x 8.27 x 9.06 inches

Best Novelty: Suck UK UFO Glass Cookie Jar

Suck UK UFO Glass Cookie Jar

Amazon

What We Like
  • Unique design

  • Airtight lid

What We Don't Like
  • Narrow mouth

Traditional cookie jars are all well and good, but if you’re looking for something out of this world, this novelty jar looks like an alien UFO sucking up cookies with a tractor beam. The UFO-shaped lid is made of cork and forms a tight seal around the mouth of the glass jar. As for the container itself, it’s made of soda lime glass, which gives it an otherworldly green tint. It’s a simple, but effective design that can serve as a conversation starter. Just watch out for little green men trying to steal your treats. 

Material: Glass, cork |  Weight: 15 ounces | Dimensions: 5.7 x 7.5 x 5.7 inches

Best for Kids: PTC Ceramic Dragon Cookie Jar

PTC Ceramic Dragon Cookie Jar

Walmart

What We Like
  • Detailed design

  • Hand painted

What We Don't Like
  • No airtight seal

  • Pricey

Cookie jars don’t have to be boring. If you’re looking for a colorful and fun design to entice kids, this dragon-shaped cookie jar is vibrant, detailed, and certainly eye-catching. Everything from the tiny scales to the reptilian eyes is hand-painted, making the jar look like it’s about to come to life. It’s made of sturdy ceramic, but should still be handled gently to prevent chipping. This fire-breathing creature will guard your cookies like a precious treasure hoard. 

Material: Ceramic | Weight: 2.3 pounds | Dimensions: 9.5 x 7 x  6.25 inches

Final Verdict

We give the top spot to Oxo’s Good Grips 3-Quart Pop Medium Cookie Jar for its space-saving design and pop-button airtight lid. A good budget choice is Style Setter’s Chalkboard Glass Canister Set. It comes with three different sizes of glass jars, each with chalkboard labels.

What to Look for in a Cookie Jar

Style

There are countless styles and designs for cookie jars. Some are round and squat, while others are tall cylinders. Some are centerpieces with eye-catching designs, while others are more utilitarian and built to save space. Additionally, there are colorful and uniquely shaped jars. Find a style, color, or shape that appeals to you or matches the rest of your kitchen décor. There’s a cookie jar out there for everyone. 

Capacity

Since cookie jars are designed to hold treats, it’s important to know just how much capacity a jar has. Unfortunately, many manufacturers use different units of measurement to signify capacity. Some might use ounces, while others use liters. To get a better understanding of size, be sure to look up the dimensions and read up on reviewer feedback-–many will comment on if a jar was too small or how many cookies they were able to fit into it. 

Lid Type 

There are many different types of cookie jar lids, including metal screw-tops and simple glass toppers. Many jars nowadays have rubber or silicone rings to make an airtight seal. Metal, glass, ceramic, stoneware, plastic, and cork are the most common materials for cookie jar lids. Ultimately, it comes down to preference as to which lid type is best. 

Ease of Access

A cookie jar that’s difficult to reach into or open defeats its purpose. It’s supposed to hold your cookies, not hold them hostage. Look for cookie jars with wide mouths and easy-to-open lids.

FAQs

Do cookie jars keep cookies fresh?

The key to keeping cookies fresh is an airtight seal. Many (if not most) cookie jars will come with a rubber ring that keeps air from getting into the jar. Cookie jars without airtight seals may not protect cookies from getting stale at a normal rate, but they do still function as an eye-pleasing container. 

How long do cookies stay fresh in a cookie jar? 

If the cookie jar has an airtight seal, cookies can stay fresher for longer. However, how long it remains fresh depends on the type of cookie and whether or not it was freshly baked. For example, cookies with frosting or filling may get stale quicker than your average chocolate chip—even inside a cookie jar. It’s recommended to eat a fresh batch of cookies within the first few days for peak freshness. If you want cookies to last beyond a week, we recommend freezing them instead of storing them in a jar. 

What material is best for a cookie jar? 

Glass, ceramic, and plastic are the three most common materials for cookie jars, and each has pros and cons. Glass is aesthetically pleasing, readily available, and transparent, so you can see the treats inside. However, it can get heavy and risk shattering if you drop it. Ceramic is another classic choice and can come in a variety of colors and designs. Ceramic is prone to chipping, however, and some ceramic jars don’t come with a rubber airtight seal. Plastic is an affordable option and is often built to save space or stack, but some people feel it looks a little cheap. 

How We Researched

To compile this list, our team of editors and contributors spent hours researching the best products on the market in this category, evaluating their key features—like ease of use, material, or price—in addition to reviews from customers and other trusted sources. We then used this research to assign a star rating from one to five (five being the best; one being the worst) to certain products on the list.

Why Trust the Spruce Eats?

Allison Wignall was definitely guilty of stealing cookies from many cookie jars in her childhood—especially from her grandpa’s stash of gingersnaps. She practically grew up in the kitchen making all kinds of cookies with her mother. Mexican wedding cake cookies are her absolute favorite. Allison’s work has been featured in publications such as Food & Wine, Travel + Leisure, and Southern Living. 

Article Sources
The Spruce Eats uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
  1. The 6 Best Cookie Jars Of 2022. Delish. https://www.delish.com/kitchen-tools/cookware-reviews/g40408403/best-cookie-jars/

Continue to 5 of 10 below.
Continue to 9 of 10 below.