Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
There are a lot of new options out there for home cooks who want to whip up a batch of fresh cookies from a mix. Today you can find mixes for everything from simple home-style cookies to the fancier types usually found at high-end bakeries. These cookie mixes make it easy to bake cookies without the time involved in totally “from scratch” baking, and that leaves more time for enjoying the tasty treats.
So where do you start? There are cookies for gifting, cookies for late-afternoon snacking, and cookies to make with children for a fun (and definitely educational) afternoon. We curated this list of mixes to include the best, the newest, and the chic-est of cookies, as well as the classics.
Here, the best store-bought cookie mixes for your next baking adventure.
Best Overall: Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Baking Mix
Betty Crocker has been around for a century so it's no wonder the brand is a trusted name in baking. The Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Baking Mix is not only practical and very affordable, but it also makes top-of-the-line cookies that are suitable as simple drop cookies or for use with cookie cutters. The best part is how simple it is to whip up the batch of sugar cookies: just add butter and water! Prep time? 5 minutes. Bake time? 9 minutes. Baking cookies doesn't get much easier than that. Decorate with frosting, sprinkles, sifted confectioners' sugar, and icing, or leave them as is—either way, they’re delicious!
Best Peanut Butter: Krusteaz Bakery Style Double Peanut Butter Cookie Mix
The saying “just like homemade” is true for these peanut butter cookies, and the time savings over “from scratch” is considerable. Krusteaz Bakery Style Double Peanut Butter Cookie Mix includes peanut butter chips, which really raises the bar on store-bought cookie mix. The two-pack makes enough for a crowd (each box makes 12 large or 18 medium-size cookies) so there's enough to share if you're feeling generous. You can mix in white or dark chocolate chips to make the recipe your own!
Beyond delicious cookies, the brand has a great story. The Krusteaz Company is a woman-founded brand, which was started in 1932. The company is active in philanthropic initiatives and has lots of creative ideas for personalizing its products to your family’s tastes—check out the website and blog for ideas and inspiration!
Best Fortune Cookies: Williams Sonoma DIY Fortune Cookie Kit
If you’ve never made fortune cookies before, this kit takes you through the process! It includes all the ingredients (sugar, flour, cocoa powder) you need, a reusable baking mat, recipes, and instructions, as well as a collection of pre-written fortunes and some blank ones along with an edible ink marker for you to write your own! This cookie kit is so much fun and is great for parties, holidays, birthdays, or as a project you can do with kids! One kit will make 40 fortune cookies. This also makes a fantastic, original gift for almost anyone on your list.
Best Gluten-Free: Pillsbury Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix
Chocolate chip cookies may be one of the most famous American cookies, and baking them for those who are gluten-intolerant isn’t always easy. This mix does a good job of replicating the flavor of the traditional cookie, is quick and easy to use, and is safe for serving anyone adhering to a gluten-free diet. All you need is butter, water, and an egg. Then, form the cookies, plop them on a baking sheet, and bake for 8-10 minutes. Want to get creative? A favorite adaptation is to use the mix to make a “cookie pie," which is quite a luxurious treat!
Best Vegan: Foodstirs Junk-Free Bakery Organic Chocolate Chippy Cookie Baking Mix
If you’re looking for a great vegan-friendly cookie mix, this is it! With “junk free” as the brand motto, these cookies are made with only organic, quality ingredients. So even if you aren't vegan, you'll be tempted by the ingredient list (and can simply add your egg and butter, for more traditional chocolate chip cookies). The Foodstirs company was started by three parents who were determined to create affordable, time-saving products for other families looking for “junk-free” delicious sweets. These cookies are “lower sugar," USDA organic, non-GMO, kosher, and made with Fair Trade chocolate and organic cane sugar.
Best Macaron: Angel Bake French Macaron Baking Mix With Swiss Buttercream Filling
French macarons seem to have become everyone’s favorite cookie lately. Maybe it’s because they’re so beautiful, or it could be that they’re both sophisticated and different. Macarons (not to be confused with macaroons) are usually something bought at bakeries, but they’re fairly easy to make at home, once you get the knack. If you’d like to make your own, this kit is a great way to start! The mixes for vanilla cookie shells and buttercream filling are both included, with directions, but you can add flavorings or colors to create your own personal style. These are a little more involved so you will need a stand mixer and pastry bag. One kit makes 24 complete macarons.
Best Red Velvet: Williams Sonoma Red Velvet Cookie Mix
Red velvet cookies are becoming more popular, and this mix makes them so easy to make—just add butter and an egg. Williams Sonoma Red Velvet Cookie Mix will produce a batch of cookies that are chic and simple, red and rich, and made with the finest organic flour that’s custom milled at a company dating back to 1856. They’re gorgeous just as they are, but a dusting of confectioners' sugar makes them even prettier. Or if you’d like to frost them, a cream cheese frosting (recipe included) is divine. The kit makes 12 large or 24 regular cookies.
Best Madeleine: Sur la Table Malted Vanilla Madeleines
Madeleines: Are they cookies or are they actually little cakes? Regardless, madeleines are elegant and desirable. We eat them with our fingers, not with a fork, and they’re the size of a large cookie, so they’re suitable for adding to a cookie collection when you want something a little special and out-of-the-ordinary. The Sur La Table Malted Vanilla Madeleines mix makes it super easy to make madeleines at home. You’ll need a madeleine pan rather than a cookie sheet to make these, but the effect is worth it! The mix makes three dozen madeleines.
Best Gingerbread: Williams Sonoma Gingerbread Cookie Mix
A good gingerbread cookie is hard to find, but with this mix, you can make a batch right at home (all you'll need to add is butter and an egg). The mix, developed by Williams Sonoma, makes homestyle gingerbread cookies that are soft, chewy, and rich with the flavor of molasses and spice. Sprinkle the tops with demerara sugar for texture and crunch. The mix can also be used to roll out gingerbread men and decorate with royal icing or sprinkles for a special treat! One package makes three dozen 2-inch cookies. It's also certified kosher.
For a quick, easy, inexpensive cookie with great flavor that’s endlessly adaptable (think frosting, flavor extracts, sprinkles) the Betty Crocker Sugar Cookie Baking Mix (view at Amazon) can’t be beaten. If a home-style cookie is what you’re looking for, Krusteaz Bakery Style Double Peanut Butter Cookie Mix (view at Amazon) is exceptional and will delight any peanut butter cookie fans out there.
Why Trust The Spruce Eats?
Karen Resta is a writer specializing in food culture and history, cooking, pastries, and restaurants. She's also a former pastry chef and has traveled to Budapest, Kyiv, and Paris during their Fashion Weeks as a photographer and writer, always finding the best authentic pastries along the way. She now spends a lot of her free time baking at home and recommends quality within your given budget. Having the right tools available and knowing how to use them well (it can take practice, like anything else) makes all the difference, and she curated this list with that in mind.