Best Dessert Subscription Boxes

Get your sweets fix with these delicious options

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Cupcakes sitting on a counter

linashib / Twenty20

For many of us, a meal just isn't complete without dessert. It doesn't matter whether it's a decadent indulgence or a bite-sized confection; we simply need the final note to be a sweet one.

The problem is that dessert can be a lot of work, especially if you value novelty. A dessert subscription box is a great solution. A steady supply of assorted sweets—delivered directly to your dwelling—saves you enormous amounts of time and effort, and ensures that all your meals will conclude properly. Forge ahead to learn more about our picks for the best dessert subscription boxes.

Best Dessert Subscription Boxes of 2021

Best Overall: Phivi



Why We Chose It: For quality, variety, and value, no one does a better dessert box than Phivi.

What We Like
  • Personalized boxes

  • Great value

What We Don't Like
  • No vegan or gluten-free options

Phivi (pronounced fee-vee) is a slightly mysterious outfit. According to its website, the company is "a local community of people discovering and booking services from event professionals for weddings, birthdays, corporate events and more." It's not entirely clear how such a service is related to a dessert subscription box, but don't let that trouble you. Phivi is definitely making it happen, and people are taking notice.

One customer put it this way: "I’m a new Phivifever customer and just got my first box. I couldn’t be happier. The packaging was fantastic and EVERYTHING (I mean everything!) was delicious!! They were not your run of the mill, mass-produced desserts. So much more than that. I am so glad that I did the 12-month subscription because I can’t wait to enjoy tasty treats like this each month!!!"

Phivi's box is called "Phivi Fever." Each monthly shipment contains an assortment of eight or more artisanal items, sourced from bakeries throughout the New York City area. Past selections include Napoleon cake, a chai cupcake jar, maple brown butter pumpkin bundt cake, tiramisu truffles, and a cobweb brownie (from an October box). Each month has a theme, and Phivi even personalizes your box using information like your birth month and favorite color.

A monthly subscription sells for around $35, with price breaks when you sign up for three, six, or 12 months. Shipping is free throughout the United States.

Best Ice Cream Box: Jeni's



Why We Chose It: Four different pints of top-quality ice cream every month is an ice cream lover's dream.

What We Like
  • Unique flavors

  • Free shipping

What We Don't Like
  • Expensive

There's nothing mysterious about Jeni's. Not only does the company share information about its ingredients and suppliers, but as a certified B corporation, Jeni's regularly submits to a transparent assessment of its social and environmental impact as well.

Founded by Jeni Britton Bauer in 2002, the company operates scoop shops in more than a dozen states and distributes pints nationwide. Jeni's makes more than 20 unique flavors, including Boston cream pie, brown butter almond brittle, gooey butter cake, sweet cream biscuits, and peach jam, and middle west whiskey and pecans.

The Pint Club is Jeni's ice cream subscription box. Each month brings a curated selection of four different ice creams, chosen from Jeni's signature flavors, as well as new varieties not yet in grocers’ freezers. The first shipment includes a welcome letter with the dates of your upcoming shipments, plus a set of ice cream spades.

The Pint Club is not a recurring subscription; you pay upfront for either three, six, or 12 months. Three months costs around $200, six months is about $390, and a year sells for roughly $760. Shipping is included in the price.

Best Cookie Box: Cravory Cookies

Cravory Cookies

Cravory Cookies

Why We Chose It: Cravory's endless cookie creativity makes for the perfect cookie subscription box.

What We Like
  • Creative flavor combos

  • Flexible subscriptions

What We Don't Like
  • Free shipping only for orders of over two dozen cookies

Cookies and cream milkshake, cookie monster, rosemary balsamic, mint julep, and pancakes and bacon: These are just a handful of the many, many creative cookies Cravory has developed. The company has created more than 5,000 unique cookie flavors over the years and continues to generate roughly six new recipes every month. With a cookie subscription from Cravory, your palate will be treated to continuous sweet novelty.

Based in San Diego, California, Cravory was founded by two friends in 2009. Over the next five years, the company organically grew its business from online sales and local farmers market stands to a popular brick-and-mortar storefront in Point Loma. Today, Cravory cookies are stocked by dozens of San Diego retailers, and, most importantly, are shipped directly to customers nationwide.

Cravory's cookie subscriptions are sold by the half dozen, with free shipping on subscriptions of two dozen cookies or more. For fewer than two dozen cookies, shipping will cost you about $7 per box. Half a dozen cookies sell for about $13, a dozen is about $26, and two dozen is around $46. To save a few bucks, check Cravory's yelp page for discount codes.

Best Pie: Goldbelly



Why We Chose It: Goldbelly brings you the finest pies from bakeries throughout the country.

What We Like
  • Free shipping

  • Pies from many different bakeries

What We Don't Like
  • Only one pie per month

Just as no dinner is complete without dessert, no dessert subscription list would be complete without pie. For the best pie subscription, look no further than Goldbelly, an online marketplace that facilitates shipping for an amazing number of America's most iconic restaurants and artisan food producers.

The best part about Goldbelly's pie subscription is that you'll get to taste the best pies from all across the country. Goldbelly works with restaurants and bakeries from Maine to Miami, Texas to Brooklyn, Louisiana to Los Angeles, and all points in between. Search for "pie" on Goldbelly's website and click the "Editor's Pick" box on the left side of the page to get a feel for the sorts of pie that Goldbelly ships to subscribers each month.

Goldbelly's pie subscription costs around $50 per month, which includes one pie every month for the duration of your subscription. There's no option to pay as you go. You must sign up for three, six, nine, or 12 months and pay upfront. Free shipping is included to anywhere in the contiguous U.S.

Best Chocolate: Jackie's



Why We Chose It: A monthly box of Jackie's bonbons is the best way to keep the chocolate coming.

What We Like
  • Free shipping

  • Great reviews

What We Don't Like
  • No customization

Jackie's Chocolate is another beloved, yet mysterious, company. The online-only, direct-mail candy vendor doesn't bother you with any stories about Jackie, and how this person got into chocolate, preferring to serve up heaps of customer reviews instead. Scroll to the bottom of the company's website, click on "Reviews," and you'll see thousands of photos of five-star satisfied customers posing with their purchases. Whoever is running Jackie's, wherever they are, they are delivering satisfaction, and that's enough.

The beauty of Jackie's chocolate subscription could be summed up in the immortal words of Forest Gump: "You never know what you're gonna get." Well, you know that you'll get chocolate, but whether it's white, dark, or milk, filled with nuts, nougat, fruit, caramel, marshmallow, or a golden ticket, you'll just have to wait to be surprised. While we're kidding about the golden ticket, Jackie does seem determined to remain a mystery.

Jackie's chocolate subscription comes in one size: a box of about 15 assorted bonbons. You can subscribe on a recurring monthly basis, or for a fixed period of three, six, or 12 months. The monthly plan costs around $30, while the prepaid plans sell for about $90, $180, and $360, respectively. Shipping is free.

Final Verdict

A dessert subscription box is a fun and easy way to treat yourself or a loved one to a steady assortment of delightful sweets. Since subscription boxes tend to focus on one kind of dessert, the best box for you will depend on what kind of sweets you love most. If that's baked goods, go with Phivi. For ice cream, Jeni's Pint Club is the choice. Goldbelly wins with pie, Cravory with cookies, and Jackie's with assorted chocolates. Since Phivi offers the widest assortment of desserts, we recommend their dessert box as the best overall.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is a Dessert Subscription Box ?

Typically, a dessert subscription box is a recurring monthly shipment of sweets ranging from various pastries to candy and even ice cream. Since nearly everyone loves sugar, there are numerous companies offering subscriptions to products that contain it.

How Much Do Dessert Subscription Boxes Cost?

The cost really depends on what kind of dessert is on offer. You can pay as little as $20 for a monthly box of cookies or as much as $70 for an assortment of premium ice cream.

What Kinds of Desserts Come in a Dessert Subscription Box?

Most companies stick to one or two general categories of dessert. We love sweets of all kinds, and while we wish there were services that sent cake, ice cream, pie, chocolate, candy, and pastries in a single box, subscriptions tend to stick to one lane. Thus, we tried to include a variety of sweets on this list.

How We Chose the Best Dessert Subscription Boxes

We wanted most of all to represent all the major categories of dessert and looked for companies that were leaders in their specific categories, with great websites, strong customer reviews, and unique products.

Phivi is relatively new on the scene, but its box boasts excellent variety and the reviews are strong. Goldbelly is an established leader in the mail-order food world, with connections to some of the top artisans in the game. Jackie's has thousands of five-star reviews for its chocolates. Cravory bakes super creative cookies. And Jeni's makes superior ice cream in a socially responsible way.

Continue to 5 of 5 below.