We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.
An iconic dessert that originated in Key West, Florida, key lime pie is a national favorite among many. Families and bakers have their own variations, but the filling of the classic version will always contain key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and egg yolks, often in a graham cracker crust and topped with a light meringue or whipped cream.
For a taste of the best nationwide, we have put together a list of companies, restaurants, and bakeshops with the best key lime pie delivery so you can have a taste of the Keys without leaving home.
Best Key Lime Pie Delivery Services of 2023
- Best Overall: Goldbelly
- Best Award-Winning: Key Lime Pie Company
- Best for All Key Lime Products: Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe
- Best Iconic Pie: Joe’s Stone Crab
Best Overall : Goldbelly
SPRUCE15 for $15 off of minimum $50 spend, first time customers only, excludes shipping, standard T&C applies.
Why We Chose It: Goldbelly offers an assortment of key lime pies and other key lime baked goods from top vendors around the country.
Assortment of products and vendors
Free shipping included on many orders
Delivered frozen for longer shelf life
Good customer reviews
Free shipping not available on all items
Online gourmet marketplace Goldbelly offers an assortment of key lime pies from around the country. Goldbelly sells items from over a dozen other companies that make key lime pies and key lime pie-inspired products. Try key lime cheesecake from Junior’s cheesecake in Manhattan, key lime pie jars from Colada Shop, key lime pie ice cream sandwiches, and even Oprah’s Favorite Key Lime Bundt Cake. Want to stick to the classic? There are numerous options for purchasing traditional key lime pies from businesses including Little Pie Company, Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe, and more.
Pie prices vary depending on the vendor, but range from $39 to $85 for a 10-inch pie. Pies are sold as single whole pies and packs of two or three. Smaller items such as mini pies, pie bars, and pie jars are sold in larger multiples. Free shipping is available on many, but not all, orders. Pies are typically made fresh daily and are packed in dry ice and delivered frozen. Upon arrival, pies can be stored in the refrigerator for up to three days or frozen for up to two months.
Best Award-Winning : Key Lime Pie Company
Why We Chose It: Key West-based Key Lime Pie Company delivers its award-winning key lime pie nationwide.
Use of all-natural ingredients
Gluten free pie crust available
Key lime pie chocolate-dipped bars
High shipping costs, particularly for small orders
Key West-based Key Lime Pie Company serves award-winning pies all made from scratch. Once named the best pie by the American Pie Council and the best pie in Florida by USA Today, Key Lime Pie Company relies on a 100-year-old family recipe. The pie uses all-natural ingredients, real key lime juice, and a handmade graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream.
In addition to its brick-and-mortar location, Key Lime Pie Company sells its pies from its online shop for delivery anywhere in the contiguous United States. The key lime pie is available with the traditional graham cracker crust or a gluten-free version. For more key lime flavor, check out the Key Lime Pie Chocolate-Dipped Bars, which are wedges of traditional key lime pie dipped in chocolate, frozen, and eaten off of a popsicle stick. A whole pie is priced at $24.99 plus shipping. The shop's pies are also available for sale on Goldbelly.
Best for All Key Lime Products : Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe
Why We Chose It: Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe delivers its key lime pie and a variety of other key lime products to homes nationwide.
Assortment of key lime products
Variety of flavors of pie and pie bars
Gluten-free pie crust available
High shipping costs
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is the place to shop for anything and everything related to key limes. Its key lime pie has been featured on the Food Network. Kermit’s makes a classic version with real key lime juice, a graham cracker crust (gluten-free crust is also available), and fluffy whipped cream, along with two flavored versions: strawberry and coconut. A single, 9-inch key lime pie is priced at $38.95 plus overnight shipping costs.
In addition to key lime pies, Kermit’s sells an assortment of frozen key lime pie bars such as regular key lime pie dipped in dark chocolate and strawberry key lime pie dipped in white or dark chocolate. A variety of key lime cookies, key lime peanuts, key lime fudge, key lime liqueur cake, and more are also available for purchase from the online shop. Kermit's pies, pie bars, and fudge are also available for sale on Goldbelly. An added bonus: Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is a disabled veteran-owned small business and regularly supports local organizations in its shops’ communities.
Best Iconic Pie : Joe’s Stone Crab
Why We Chose It: Joe’s Stone Crab bakes its classic key lime pie daily and delivers via FedEx Overnight.
Overnight shipping is included
Good value if ordering multiple pies
Only one variety of pie
The iconic Joe’s Stone Crab in the South Beach district of Miami, Florida, is known for more than stone crabs. Its key lime pie is a signature dessert at the historic establishment that has been around since 1913. Joe’s Key Lime Pies are baked daily and are available by the slice for locals. For those of us not lucky enough to have Joe’s Stone Crab in our neighborhood, we can enjoy it as a whole pie via nationwide delivery.
Each 9-inch pie is delivered via FedEx Overnight and will arrive frozen and packed in dry ice. Customers can order up to three pies per order. Because of flat-rate shipping costs, it's beneficial to order multiple pies at once for the best value; while a single pie is $72.95, two pies are $112.95 and three pies are $134.95 (reducing the cost per pie to less than $45). In addition to key lime pie, Joe’s Stone Crab offers a large selection of other items available for home delivery to round out a delicious meal.
For those wanting a restaurant-quality key lime pie with no variations, Joe’s Stone Crab is a good bet. If you want to try some other flavors in addition to the classic, such as strawberry key lime or other key lime products, Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is our pick. Because of the great variety of pies and other key lime pie-inspired baked goods along with free shipping, Goldbelly is our best overall choice.
|Company||Best For||Price per Pie||Shipping Included||Number of Pie and Key Lime Flavored Products Available||Gluten-Free Pie Available|
|Goldbelly||Overall||Starts at $39||Yes, for most||35+||Yes|
|Key Lime Pie Co.||Award-Winning||$24.99||No||6||Yes|
|Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe||All Key Lime Products||$38.95||No||50+||Yes|
|Joe’s Stone Crab||Iconic Pie||Starts at $45||Yes||1||No|
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Origin of Key Lime Pie?
Early records show the first written recipes of key lime pie date back to the 1930s-1940s, but it was likely being made in homes long before then. There is general consensus that the first key lime pies were made in Key West, Florida, where there is an abundance of key limes. Legend has it that Florida’s first self-made millionaire, William Curry, had a cook known as Aunt Sally who created the pie in the late 1800s, while others think that this was already a delicacy first produced by an area fisherman. Some food historians claim it has a completely different origin story, including one that links it to an invention by a milk company in order to sell more sweetened condensed milk. Because of the lack of refrigeration or ice in the Keys in those early days, sweetened condensed milk was the perfect shelf-stable ingredient to use in baking.
What Are the Ingredients in Key Lime Pie?
Traditionally, a key lime pie's filling consists of key lime juice, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk. It typically sits in a graham cracker crust, although it can also be cooked in a more traditional pie crust. It is sometimes served without a topping but often has a light meringue topping made from egg whites or whipped cream. The pie is served chilled.
Why Are Key Lime Pies for Delivery So Expensive?
While $60 and up may seem quite steep for a single pie, this is due to the realities of shipping a box of frozen products via overnight or two-day expedited delivery. These are fixed costs that each company incurs that they either need to factor into the cost of each pie or add on as a delivery surcharge.
How We Chose the Best Key Lime Pie Delivery Services
To select the best services, we weighed company history and accolades, quality of ingredients used in the pies, customer reviews, and pricing. A variety of flavors and other related items were also considered. For example, Key Lime Pie Company was chosen for its previous recognition in pie contests and best pie categories in addition to its century-old family recipe, while Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe was selected for its accolades as well as its extensive selection of key lime pie products.