Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/01364d90-8571-42f3-bfe3-bc01995c1ed6.ddb050931e744eaf41920065884977ee-c2d776d2455e461a9eeeada69eff076a.jpeg)
100% pure and made from cold-pressed olives
Smooth flavor with herbal notes
Approved by the Olive Oil Commission of California
A bit expensive
California Olive Ranch describes its extra virgin olive oil as freshly pressed juice. Unlike light or refined oils, which are made with exposure to high heat or chemical solvents, this cold-pressed olive oil is made by crushing fresh olives mechanically. This not only leaves you with an olive oil that’s totally pure, but one that tastes perfectly smooth, too.
The “Everyday” blend combines several different types of olives to create a versatile oil that contains herbal, fruity, and grassy notes all in one. And, as the name implies, it’s ideal for everyday sauteing, baking, roasting, and even drizzling over salads, as many customers can attest. If you’re looking for something that tastes a little milder, but is still free of chemical solvents, the “Mild” blend has a less intense, buttery flavor.
All of California Olive Ranch’s oils are certified extra virgin by a third-party lab that tests the chemical and sensory properties of the oil. The extra virgin olive oil is also certified kosher, verified non-GMO, and carries a seal from the Olive Oil Commission of California (or OOCC), which has one of the most stringent quality standards in the world.
While some customers say a bottle of this oil is a bit more expensive than some brands they buy from the grocery store, many say it's worth the cost, particularly because of its quality and flavor.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/commerce_default_image_icon-d30e3fe926f54a6a9f8165be26203dbf.png){kind=icon}
Cold pressed
Smooth flavor with fruity notes
Inexpensive
Flavor might be too mild for some tastes
Napa Valley may be known for wine, but Napa Valleys Naturals, a brand of Stonewall Kitchen, puts the Northern California region on the map for olive oil, too. While the company started as a roadside produce stand, its operation has expanded throughout the world. Its organic extra virgin olive oil is now made of a blend of regional olives that come from the Mediterranean and are cold-pressed to create a smooth buttery flavor mixed with light, fruity notes. Customers love the taste of this olive oil, though one notes that it's a bit mild for her taste. Another says it works great as a salad dressing.
While it doesn’t really have any effect on its taste or quality, all five of its olive oil sizes, which range from 12.7 ounces to 128 ounces, are packaged in wine bottles, which just makes them feel kind of fancy.
Sourced from one region in Greece
Robust flavor
Great for drizzling
Not ideal for cooking
Although many of the olive oils on this list are cold pressed, Ellora earned the spot of best cold-pressed olive oil for several reasons. Unlike other olive oils, which combine several olive varieties from various regions, the Ellora Farms Extra Virgin Olive Oil—and all of Ellora Farms’ oils—come from a single region: Crete, Greece. But it’s not only sourced from Greece, it’s produced right on the spot using low temperatures and cold pressing to preserve both flavor and quality.
The Ellora Farms Extra Virgin Olive Oil has a rich, fruity aroma and a bold, peppery flavor that earned it a gold medal at the Mediterranean International Olive Oil Competition in 2019. Although you can cook with it, as long as you’re using low temperatures, it’s best as a finishing or drizzling oil. Customers gave this oil high marks for its well-balanced flavor.
Not too thick and not too thin
Light, fruity flavor
Great for dipping
May be too mild for some palates
If you’re looking for the best olive oil for cooking, the O-Live and Co. Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil checks all the boxes. Not only was its flavor profile—which is best described as mild and fruity—designed to complement any type of cooked dish, but it’s also one of the purest olive oils out there. Customers praise that its mild flavor doesn't have a bitter aftertaste, saying it works equally well for drizzling and cooking. The olive oil comes from Chile and far exceeds the purity standards set by the International Olive Oil Council.
In addition to their regular Everyday olive oil, O-Live and Co. also offers a certified organic option. And if you prefer a more intense, peppery olive oil over a fruity one, O-Live and Co. has your back with its “Robust” extra virgin olive oil.
100% organic
Bright, peppery flavor that isn't overpowering
Recyclable, BPA-free packaging
Design of container could be improved
While you can certainly use it for cooking, the La Tourangelle Extra Virgin Olive Oil really shines when paired with a big piece of fresh crusty bread. That’s why it’s earned the spot of best olive oil for dipping. To make the extra virgin olive oil, La Tourangelle harvests olives from Andalucia, Spain during the early season and cold presses them the same day.
This process helps prevent the loss of antioxidants, but also creates an oil that has a fresh, bright, and peppery taste with hints of almond, olive leaves, and freshly cut grass. Customers love that its flavor isn't overpowering, though some say the container could use a redesign so that the oil doesn't dribble down the side of it.
The La Tourangelle olive oil is also 100 percent organic and non-GMO verified and the tin container it’s packaged in is BPA free.
Robust flavor
Great price for the quality
Comes in three other flavor profiles
Oil is a blend from many sources
Good olive oil doesn’t have to come at a high price, and Filippo Berio’s extra virgin olive oil proves that. For a very budget-friendly price, you can get 25.3 ounces of cold-pressed olive oil that’s made in Italy from a combination of olive varieties from Italy, Spain, Greece, and Tunisia, a North African country that borders the Mediterranean Sea. The result is a robust rich-tasting olive oil that’s ideal for cooking, dressing, and marinades. While some people may be hesitant to buy this oil due to it being sourced from many regions, several customers who typically buy more expensive oils say it's a worthwhile purchase due to its quality and versatility.
In addition to getting olive oil at a great price, you also get some additional options. If you’re looking for different flavor profiles, you can opt for the Robusto, which has a peppery finish, the 100% Italian, which is light and fruity with a spicy finish, or the California, which combines a delicate balance of fruity and peppery.
Light, fresh flavor
Organic and free from preservatives
Versatile
Some flavors not as strong as others
If you’re looking for flavored olive oil, the Mantova Extra Virgin Olive Oil variety pack covers all of the bases. It combines four 8.5-ounce infused olive oils in basil, garlic, lemon, and chili. Each flavored olive oil is made from Italian olives and cold-pressed to create full-flavored oils that are free of any preservatives, additives, and artificial flavors (and certified organic, too!).
This four-pack makes a great addition to any kitchen—you can use the oils for finishing or dipping—or is a perfect gift for any food lover. And after tasting them yourself, if you decide you like one flavor better than the others, you can buy them each individually instead of in the variety pack.
People gave these flavored oils high praise for how versatile they are: they work great for dressing salads, sauteing, marinating, and—according to more than a few customers—drizzling over popcorn.
Smooth flavor profile
Made from cold-pressed organic Koroneiki olives
Great flavor and quality
Gallon size comes in plastic packaging
You may know Bragg from their wildly popular raw apple cider vinegar, but their commitment to quality and wellness extends to olive oil too. Bragg makes their extra virgin olive by cold pressing organic Koroneiki olives cultivated from Greek orchards. Customers rave about this oil's smooth flavor profile, which is ideal for all applications, including light sauteing and drizzling as a finishing oil.
Although you can get smaller sizes, their gallon (128-ounce) jug is one of the best bangs for your buck. While there are other, less expensive oils on the market, this one is a high-quality USDA certified organic, non-GMO, and certified kosher oil at an excellent price of around 40 cents per ounce.
If you’re looking for an olive oil that covers all the bases, look no further than the California Olive Ranch Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil. If you want separate oils for cooking and dipping, opt for the O-Live and Co. Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil and La Tourangelle Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil.
Why Trust The Spruce Eats?
Lindsay Boyers is a certified holistic nutritionist with extensive nutrition knowledge and cooking experience. She’s developed over 1,000 original recipes and is constantly on a mission to find the best tasting foods and beverages at the best prices.
The Ultimate Olive Oil Buying Guide
By Molly Watson
Olive oil is lauded for its health benefits as often as for its unique flavor. Not all olive oils are alike, however. Where once olive oil aficionados insisted that the only good olive oil came from Italy or France, olive oils from Spain, Greece, and California have gained recognition for their unique flavor profiles.
There are wonderful California olive oil producers, some even pressing and bottling varietal olive oils (oils from specific olive varieties). Here is information about different types of olive oils and how to buy, store, and use this delicious oil.
Key Considerations
Olive Oil Health Properties
Olive oil is mainly made up of monounsaturated fatty acids and void of cholesterol. It also contains antioxidants and vitamin E.
Olive Oil Grades
Olive oil is graded based on how the olives are processed and the acidity level of the final oil. For the maximum flavor and health benefits, buy extra virgin olive oil.
Cooking Uses for Olive Oil
When you go to the trouble and expense of buying high-quality olive oil, use it where it can shine: to dress salads and drizzle on dishes. Lesser quality olive oil can make good cooking oil.
While olive oil gets used in scads of recipes, here are a few where the flavor and even the unique texture of olive oil plays an important role:
- Marinated Baby Artichokes are cooked in a vinegar bath before being "cured" in jars of olive oil
- Smoked Paprika Soup and Fava Bean Soup both get a hit of flavor and soothing smoothness from a swirl of olive oil as a garnish
- Skordalia is a mixture of potato, almond, and olive oil used as a dip or a spread and full of olive oil flavor
- Aïoli is a garlicky homemade mayonnaise made primarily from olive oil
- Spanish Gazpacho depends on olive oil to soften the acidic edge of tomatoes
Baked goods made with olive oil stay fresher longer, just be sure to look for olive oil-specific recipes since the flavor of olive oil needs to be balanced out more than does vegetable oil or butter.
Tasting and Storing Tips
How to Taste Olive Oil
Professionals taste olive oil plain, from a spoon or small cup. They smell it first, noting aromas before tasting it. They then sip the oil and let it coat their mouths, noting levels of acid, pungency, and fruitiness.
At home, feel free to taste olive oil by dipping a piece of plain white bread into the oil (baguette or ciabatta works well) or do as the professionals do and simply slurp it plain. If it's turned rancid, as olive oil left in heat or light does quite quickly, it will have a sharp bite that isn't the desired pungency. It will make your mouth pucker instead of the kick to the back of your throat that more pungent olive oils tend to have.
How to Store Olive Oil
Heat, light, and air all affect olive oil in a negative way. Olive oil is best stored in sealable metal tins or dark glass bottles to protect the oil from the light. These darkened containers should then be kept away from light and heat. That glass bottle of olive oil next to the stove? The smart bet says that oil has become rancid.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/close-up-of-vinegar-bottles-with-salt-and-pepper-shaker-on-table-595512821-2c681c31f0a749548218007c153c1b27.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/making-cup-of-tea-1002040890-e22b0bb8fe6d463faaf77f20c5a47631.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-173807095-56a53a423df78cf772870ddf.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/wildplanetwildsockeyesalmon-7f3c406f9a514bf386a7c0c1618c68a5.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/honey-dipper-and-bread-983236752-b106aff7706046f4adb19c063a17ab8d.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-126175373-59d3b94722fa3a0011906976.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/stack-of-pancakes-with-maple-syrup--berries-and-fresh-coffee-806714158-cac469e8fdf9418ab2f40b2d8e309ccd.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/kitchenaid-7fca5e5011774d23afaac01574cd53bf.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-909215468-5ac399130e23d90036aff2de.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-640920172-61855733f4ba419a8bef9daf84b15ebf.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/a-young-woman-using-a-oven-144458680-5be372024cedfd00260edb27.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/chocolate-truffles--candies-and-sweets-store-on-showcase-in-factory-store--chocolate-bit-sized-for-sale-in-local-chocolate-store--696960482-5b116ca81d640400364d296f.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-145083263-59dcc92a519de200110073b8.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-1140662035-9fb504d30b554da38a79938db94d1ba0.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/espresso-on-a-wooden-table-497031116-5dfb1817127e4969a8f063b3c534cc41.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/SPRE_PlaceholderImage-5aeb39defa6bcc0036308805.png)