Our Top Picks
Best Overall Oven Mitts: HOMWE Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt at Amazon
"If you’re in camp oven mitt, this pair is sure to exceed your expectations."
Best Overall Pot Holders: Ritz Royale Collection 100% Cotton Terry Cloth Pot Holder at Amazon
"Traditionalists will love this old school pot holder."
Best Budget: Ikea ALVALISA Pot Holder at Ikea
"Don’t let the low price tag fool you into thinking these pot holders can’t get the job done."
Best With Fingers: Grill Armor Extreme Heat-Resistant Oven Gloves at Amazon
"These oven gloves will let your five fingers be free."
Best for Large Hands: Big Red House Oven Mitts at Amazon
"These mitts fit comfortably over big hands."
Best Silicone: OXO Good Grips Silicone Pot Holder at oxo.com
"This pot holder is more comfortable to hold than many others made from silicone."
Best Hybrid Pot Holder/Oven Mitt: Ritz Royale Cloth Mitz at Amazon
"This design offers a best-of-both-worlds quality."
If you’re reaching for folded up dish towels to handle the hot stuff in your kitchen, it’s time to consider some new and safer options. You need better gear to protect yourself from molten hot pizza stones, fajita-sizzling cast iron, scorching splashes of boiling pasta water, and chili-filled Dutch ovens that weigh a ton. There’s a pot holder or oven mitt out there that will match your kitchen, feel comfortable in your hand, and keep you free from burns.
01 of 07
Best Overall Oven Mitts: HOMWE Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt
Many modern oven mitts incorporate silicone into their design. This can result in thick, bulky, and hard-to-maneuver mitts. But these mitts are thinner and more flexible than you’d expect. They give you all the dexterity you want in the kitchen. They’re also lightweight and stand up to heavy use.
The lightly patterned surface makes them exceptionally grippy. The design offers ample coverage to protect your arms as well as your hands from the heat of the oven and hot pots and pans. If you’re in camp mitt, this pair is sure to exceed your expectations.
02 of 07
Best Overall Pot Holders: Ritz Royale Collection 100% Cotton Terry Cloth Pot Holder
The trend in pot holders and oven mitts alike has been toward higher-tech materials and novel designs in recent years, but traditionalists will love this old school pot holder. It will likely remind you of the ones your grandmother has used since before you were born. Fluffy terry cloth provides better heat protection than flat fabrics.
It conforms easily to pot handles when you grab them, leaving heavy hot items feeling secure in your grasp. Yet it isn’t flimsy—the terry cloth can stand up to cast iron skillets that have been roasting in a 500-degree oven. When these pot holders get grimy, just toss them in the washer and dryer. Another bonus? The timeless, no-frill squares will also double as trivets.
03 of 07
Best Budget: Ikea ALVALISA Pot Holder
These bright and cheery green and white pot holders are so cute, you’ll proudly hang them in your kitchen. One side features small green polka dots, and the flip side has large ones in white. Don’t let the low price tag fool you into thinking these pot holders can’t get the job done. The exterior is 100 percent cotton, but it’s filled with insulating polyester wadding that will save your hands from the heat.
These feel soft and comfortable to the touch—you might be inspired to bake more just to have an excuse to put them through their paces. But remember, though these can definitely take a spin in your washer, you’ll want to hang them up to dry to extend their life.
04 of 07
Best With Fingers: Grill Armor Extreme Heat-Resistant Oven Gloves
Thick and sturdy but lightweight, these oven gloves will let your five fingers be free. The surface is trimmed with silicone grips to keep pot handles and utensils firmly in hand. You can confidently reach into your hot oven and move things around without worrying about burns.
The cuff means your wrists will be protected as well. If you’ve ever felt like a traditional oven mitt hinders your freedom of movement and ability to grab hot stuff, these are just the thing you’ve been looking for. Remember, like most oven mitts and pot holders, these aren’t waterproof, and if they get wet, you’re more likely to get burned.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
05 of 07
Best for Large Hands: Big Red House Oven Mitts
These mitts fit comfortably over big hands thanks to a spacious interior. They were designed by a chef who knows what home cooks want in their oven mitts. And even though there’s plenty of space for meaty paws, they are also comfortable for smaller hands as well, making them a good choice in multi-cook households.
They have a good combo of silicone and cotton, so they're easy to maneuver while still being great for grabbing hot items. The terry cloth lining makes them comfy to wear and even more heat resistant.
06 of 07
Best Silicone: OXO Good Grips Silicone Pot Holder
This pot holder is more comfortable to hold than many others made from silicone. It’s also surprisingly agile in your hand. A silicone ring is attached for easy hanging, and though you can’t toss these in the washing machine, the pot holder wipes up very easily after splatters or spills.
It’s available in neutral white and black as well as cherry red, should you want a pop of color for your kitchen. Like other pot holders of this style, it can serve as a trivet at the table.
07 of 07
Best Hybrid Pot Holder/Oven Mitt: Ritz Royale Cloth Mitz
Can’t decide between pot holders and oven mitts? This design offers a best-of-both-worlds quality, straddling the oven mitt/pot holder divide. They’re easier to maneuver than typical oven mitts yet offer more coverage than your standard pot holder. They’re also a snap to put on and off. These hybrids are made from sturdy cotton and terry cloth, and they can go into your washer and dryer.
The world can be divided into two types of people: Those who prefer the freedom of pot holders and those who want the full coverage of oven mitts. For a classic, no-frills pot holder, get the Ritz Royale Collection 100% Cotton Terry Cloth option. If an oven mitt is what you’re after, opt for the HOMWE Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt.