Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Cuisinart Chef's Stainless 16-Inch Roaster at Amazon
"With a professional stainless exterior, this sleek roasting pan is not only aesthetically pleasing, but also incredibly well made."
Runner-Up, Best Overall: KitchenAid Stainless Steel Roaster at Amazon
"Customers give this roasting pan a perfect rating, citing how solid and durable it is, plus how great the food comes out."
Best Budget: Wilton Recipe Right Roasting Pan at Amazon
"Made of heavy-gauge steel that makes things heat and cook evenly."
Best High End: Calphalon Roaster with Roasting Rack at Amazon
"If you’re looking for a higher end roaster with mostly rave reviews, this is the one."
Best Disposable: Catering Essentials Deep Full Size Pans at Amazon
"[I] buy disposable roasting pans every year for a family function and these were the best they’ve purchased."
Best Cast Iron: Cuisinart Chef's Cast Iron Roasting Pan at Amazon
"This pan is great for roasting a chicken or an average-sized beef or pork roast."
Best Large Capacity: Granite Ware Rectangular Roaster at Amazon
"It can fit a turkey up to 30 pounds without the lid, or 24 pounds with it on, and it is dishwasher safe."
01 of 07
Best Overall: Cuisinart Chef's Classic Stainless 16-Inch Rectangular Roaster
With a professional stainless exterior, this sleek roasting pan is not only aesthetically pleasing, but also incredibly well made. It has riveted stainless steel handles, which makes it easy to take in and out of the oven. The included stainless steel rack is great for cooking meat or poultry as it allows the meat or poultry to drain while it roasts. At 16 inches, the roaster is able to handle your typical turkey, chicken, or large pot roast with ease. Plus, it’s dishwasher safe, which makes cleaning up a breeze, and it also comes with a limited lifetime warranty.
Customers who have purchased this roasting pan have raved about its quality for the price. Reviewers praised how evenly it cooks your food and the fact that it is easy to clean. A few consumers said they were expecting it to be a little heavier and that the stainless steel feels a little thinner than other roasting pans. Overall, the majority of customers were pleased with this purchase and would recommend it to others.
02 of 07
Runner-Up, Best Overall: KitchenAid Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Roaster with Rack
This 16x13x3 nonstick stainless steel roasting pan is not only going to help you make a delicious turkey, but it’s also pretty enough to place on the table when the food is ready. It’s got contoured stainless steel cast handles that give you a more comfortable grip for easy transport, plus it’s heavy duty enough to withstand heat of up to 500 degrees. The U-shaped rack allows the heat to circulate evenly for a crisp browning. And cleanup will be a breeze since this is dishwasher safe.
An overwhelming majority of customers give this roasting pan a perfect rating, citing how solid and durable it is, plus how great the food comes out when using it. While it might feel a little heavy at eight pounds, it’s great quality and will do a lovely job every time. Bonus: there’s a limited lifetime warranty.
03 of 07
Best Budget: Wilton Recipe Right Large Roasting Pan
If you aren’t sure how often you’ll use your roasting pan, you probably won’t want to spend a lot. That’s where this popular pan from Wilton comes in handy. It’s made of heavy-gauge steel that makes things heat and cook evenly. It also has a nonstick coating that makes it easy to get the food out of there and lessens the work of cleaning. The only drawback is that it’s not dishwasher safe, but customers have reported that it’s easy to clean by hand.
Because of its large size, 17 by 13 inches, it can accommodate a family sized meal with ease, said one of the reviewers. Many have also praised its size as great for a turkey and its sturdiness, especially for the low price. A small selection of customers have reported the nonstick peeling off over time though. However, most reviewers were very satisfied with the roasting pan’s performance and quality.
04 of 07
Best High End: Calphalon Stainless 16-Inch Roaster with Roasting Rack
Care to splurge a bit on a roasting pan? This one is a great choice if you’re looking for a high-quality product. Layers of stainless steel surround a heavy gauged aluminum core, giving the pan superior conductibility and extreme durability. It has a beautifully sleek design featuring a nonstick V-rack, brushed stainless steel handles, and a clear tempered-glass lid, which is helpful in cooking casseroles or keeping food warm after you’ve removed it from the oven. This roasting pan can also be used on the stove, so if you want to make a large amount of gravy or baked beans for example, you can do that as well. Also, thanks to the non-porous surface, you can also use whatever utensil you want on it. When it’s time to clean up, you can toss it in the dishwasher. Plus, you’ll rest assured that if anything happens to it, the pan comes with a limited lifetime warranty.
Most customers have been extremely satisfied with their purchase, praising the design and quality. A few people had issues with the rack being too flimsy. But if you’re looking for a higher end roaster with mostly rave reviews, this is the one.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
05 of 07
Best Disposable: Catering Essentials Deep Full Size Pans, Set of 15
Sometimes you just need a disposable roasting pan. Perhaps you’re going to a barbecue or potluck dinner party and don’t want to have to tote your good one along with you. A disposable one can work — just don’t go expecting too many bells and whistles. This simple one is a good buy. Each pan in the set of 15 is made of 65 gauge aluminum with full curl rim and can hold up to 13 pounds of food.
One customer said that they buy disposable roasting pans every year for a family function and these were the best they’ve purchased. They added that the pans are very sturdy and strong and don’t need any additional support for heavy foods. Another praised the product for keeping hot food warm for a reasonable amount of time. A couple of have people said that the pans arrived damaged though. But the majority of customers were satisfied with the quality of the product and would recommend it.
If you don't need a pan that's quite so large, these are also available in half-size, but come in packs of 30 pans.
06 of 07
Best Cast Iron: Cuisinart Chef's Classic Enameled Cast Iron Roasting Pan
Cast iron has several advantages when it comes to cookware. It retains heat well, and it provides very even heat distribution with no hot spots. The downside is that it’s heavy. Uncoated cast iron needs some special care, but this roasting pan is fully coated, so you can even wash it in the dishwasher. This one is available with either a red or blue exterior with a white interior. It’s also safe for use under the broiler.
While this pan is great for roasting a chicken or an average-sized beef or pork roast, it’s a too small for roasting something like a huge turkey – the exterior dimensions are 10.3 x 18 x 3, so make sure you food will fit.
07 of 07
Best Large Capacity: Granite Ware 0511-3 Covered Rectangular Roaster
Cooking for a crowd? This large roasting pan is a great option. It features carbon steel construction and a porcelain surface, which helps it distribute heat evenly. According to the company, it’s safer than foil roasters and can brown foods better as well. Also thanks to its inert glass surface, it won’t retain the flavors or smells of past recipes. Using it for Thanksgiving? It can fit a turkey up to 30 pounds without the lid, or 24 pounds with it on. Best of all (if you’re in charge of cleaning up), it’s dishwasher safe.
The majority of customers love cooking large things with this roaster, with many saying it will hold the largest turkey they’ll ever have to buy. Praise has been given to the taste of the food from the pan and one person said that with the lid, it can be a very nice lobster steamer too. Another hack mentioned in the reviews is using is as a dish pan. So many possibilities! Some customers have been less satisfied with the overall quality of the product, but if it’s something that you plan to use infrequently, this should do the trick.
What to Look for in a Roasting Pan
Size When thinking about what size roasting pan you need, consider what type of food you want to roast. If you like to cook up a gigantic turkey for the holidays, you’ll need a large pan, but if you’re just planning to roast chickens, vegetables and other smaller dishes, ta smaller one may be sufficient. Also, consider how much storage space you have.
Material Roasters are made from a variety of materials, and each will cook your foods slightly differently and require different methods of care. Stainless steel models are durable but aren't always the easiest to clean. Some pans have nonstick surfaces that help with cleanup, but in those cases, you have to be careful with the utensils you use to avoid scratching the surface. Some are disposable, so you don’t have to worry about cleanup at all.
Features Do you want a lid with your roaster? How about a roasting rack? There are models that come with both, as well as those that are just bare-bones. Also, when looking at a pan, check to see what type of handles it has and if you find them comfortable to use.