11 Essential and Popular Rum Tiki Cocktails

Tiki cocktails are a ton of fun and just one part of the larger tiki bar scene. It may be a little more underground than it was in its heyday of the 1940s and '50s, yet it's still alive and well. Tiki parties remain a popular theme for many and the drinks below are the most popular cocktails for such an occasion. First, however, let's take a look at what goes into a tiki cocktail.

What Is a Tiki Cocktail?

There is no real definition of what makes a drink worthy of the "tiki" label. However, there are some characteristics found in almost every tiki cocktail.

  • Rum, and lots of it. Most tiki cocktails include at least one rum, though many combine up to three different styles.
  • Loads of tropical fruits. In true tropical style, tiki drinks include fruit juices and many recipes include more than one. Be sure to have a good supply of fruits like pineapple, orange, passion fruit, guava, and coconut. The flavor is often dominated by fruits and that helps hide the heavy taste of alcohol. This is perfect for drinkers who prefer less alcohol flavor, and yet, that also makes them slightly more dangerous. They end up tasting so good that a person can almost forget how potent they really are.
  • Layers of flavor. Those first two characteristics are an indication that these drinks are anything but boring or simple. The tiki cocktail will often have four or more ingredients that create a great depth to the drink's flavor.
  • Spices make an appearance. Though not a requirement in a tiki cocktail, you will find that many have an ingredient that adds just a touch of spice. Pimento dram, spiced rum, and spices like nutmeg can be found in a number of these drinks.
  • Many ways to make one drink. For one reason or another, tiki cocktails are the most likely drink recipes to have multiple variations. Almost every drink on this list has had ingredients added, subtracted, and substituted multiple times over the years. Some barely resemble what the bartending community accepts as the original recipe. Why is that? One theory is that the recipes were often kept secret for so long that bartenders began interpreting what may be in them. There is so much going on in these drinks that it can be difficult to pinpoint each ingredient, so they gave it their best guess.
1:15

Watch Now: Popular Recipe for the Zombie Tiki Cocktail

  • 01 of 11

    Mai Tai

    Mai tai cocktail

    The Spruce

     

    The Mai Tai is the ultimate tiki cocktail and it is the creation of Victor Bergeron, one of the founders of the tiki bar scene. His famous bar, Trader Vic's, is home to the original Mai Tai and it is a very fine drink.

    Over the years, the Mai Tai has taken on a much fruitier taste than Bergeron intended. The original recipe uses two rums, lime juice, orange curaçao, and orgeat and simple syrups. It is actually quite dry compared to many of the modern interpretations.

  • 02 of 11

    Zombie

    Zombie cocktail

    The Spruce

    Donn Beach of the famous Donn the Beachcomber bar was Bergeron's rival in the early tiki days and the Zombie is one of his original recipes. It is also one of the most complex recipes you will find.

    This particular recipe is Dale DeGroff's interpretation. It includes light and dark rums, orange curaçao, a trio of citrus juices, passion fruit puree, grenadine, and bitters. There is also an option of floating 151-proof rum on top of the finished drink.

    The Zombie may also win the prize for the most recipe variations and you have to be careful because a few are simply too strong to enjoy. It may be that some people took the name too literally and created monstrosities out of what is a very tasty cocktail.

  • 03 of 11

    Hurricane

    Classic Hurricane drink recipe

    The Spruce / Julia Hartbeck

    The Hurricane was and still is the signature cocktail of New Orleans' Pat O'Brien's bar and it was first created around 1940. You can still get the same great taste at any of the bar's locations in the U.S.

    For this cocktail, you'll mix light and dark rums, passion fruit juice, orange juice, lime juice, simple syrup, and grenadine. It is one of the tastiest tiki cocktails and the fruity combination is hard to resist.

  • 04 of 11

    Navy Grog

    Navy grog cocktail

    The Spruce Eats / Teena Agnel

    The two tiki bar legends mentioned above have both taken credit for this modernized Navy Grog cocktail. Yet, neither can claim to have invented the Navy Grog because it was the name given to the daily rum ration of British sailors in the 1700s.

    Rum and lime juice are the only ingredients that everyone can seem to agree on when it comes to the Navy Grog. Yet, one thing's for sure, you will need to have ​a good supply of rum to mix up any of these recipes.

    Continue to 5 of 11 below.
  • 05 of 11

    Rum Runner

    Rum Runner

    The Spruce

    Creators of tropical cocktails just cannot seem to agree on ingredients and the Rum Runner is another example of a great drink with many recipes. No matter how you make it, it is a fun one.

    One of the best Rum Runner recipes includes light and dark rums, banana liqueur, blackberry liquor, orange juice, pineapple juice, and grenadine. Others include the spices of falernum instead of sweet grenadine or they may skip either of the juices. In general, a Rum Runner should have rum, banana, and blackberry, but this is not always the case either.

  • 06 of 11

    Bahama Mama

    Bahama Mama Cocktail Recipe

     The Spruce

    The Bahama Mama brings coffee into the mix via a liqueur and goes straight for the bottles of dark and over-proof rum. It also tends to be heavy on the pineapple and the entire mix comes together in true boozy tropical perfection.

    If you like, there is a second Bahama Mama recipe that features coconut rum and cuts the pineapple while adding orange juice. It is also a fruity delight and is fun to toss into the blender.

  • 07 of 11

    Jungle Bird

    Jungle Bird Cocktail

    S&C Design Studios

    If you're looking for a great-tasting rum cocktail that gives you the chance to play with a cool garnish, it's hard to beat this jungle bird recipe. Rum, pineapple, and lime are present but also Campari, which is not typically seen in tropical cocktails.

  • 08 of 11

    Painkiller

    Painkiller cocktail recipe

    ​The Spruce / Cara Cormack

    Painkiller recipes do not vary as much as the other tiki cocktails. You're pretty safe in stocking from this recipe's ingredient list because any variations are just a matter of changing proportions.

    The key ingredient is nutmeg. Without it, you're looking at something similar to a Pina Colada, which is a great drink in its own right. Yet, if you're looking to go from "tropical" to "tiki," then you will not want to forget that touch of spice.

    Continue to 9 of 11 below.
  • 09 of 11

    Scorpion

    Scorpion Rum Tiki Cocktail

    S&C Design Studios

    The Scorpion is a potent mixed drink and, for the first time, brandy makes an appearance. It should not be that surprising because brandy had been mixed with tropical and citrus fruits long before the tiki bars were even a dream.

    As is the case with many of these cocktails, drinkers who mix up a round of Scorpions often go too far with the booze. This kind of thinking often leads to drunkenness and nasty hangovers. With three spirits, this is already a strong drink, so don't burn it by overpouring. Instead, appreciate it for the delicious tropical drink that it is and enjoy the fact that you can remember it the next day.

    The scorpion bowl is also a great option that can be enjoyed with friends.

  • 10 of 11

    Blue Hawaiian

    Blue Hawaii cocktail

    The Spruce

    The Blue Hawaiian is a bit more mellow than other tiki cocktails and it is a beautiful shade of green-blue. This is the ultimate poolside cocktail and you will find that it is very easy to shake up.

    You may notice that it looks a lot like a Pina Colada and you would be right. Adding blue curacao gives the Blue Hawaiian its signature color and, just like the colada, you can blend this beauty up as well.

  • 11 of 11

    Beachcomber

    Beachcomber Cocktail

    S&C Design Studios

    The Beachcomber is the lightest of these tiki cocktails and it is the only drink not served in a tall glass. It is much more like a rum sour than the typical tiki drink, yet it's fun and super easy and you'll love it all the same.

    By the name, you might think that Donn the Beachcomber created this one, but the recipe is actually attributed to Trader Vic's. It's an odd twist and one that might not be entirely true, but it's always fun to have some bar trivia to debate over drinks!

How Did the Tiki Bar Begin?

Ernest Raymond Beaumont Grant (aka Donn Beach) opened the first tiki bar in 1934 on Hollywood Boulevard in Los Angeles. The bar was the now-famous Don the Beachcomber and was decorated with items reminiscent of islands in the South Pacific. Beach developed a cocktail menu that celebrated the many styles of rum he had tasted over the years in elaborate, very secret recipes.

Around that same time, Victor Bergeron transformed his Oakland, California, saloon Hinky Dinks into Trader Vic's after touring the South Pacific islands. At his new tropical-themed bar, Bergeron created rum drinks in the same fashion and with the same prestige (and secrecy) as Beach. The two became rivals as well as the pioneers of the tiki bar. Both establishments expanded into chains and continue to operate today.

Post World War II, the interest in Polynesian culture blossomed and tiki cocktails took off. Soon, tiki bars popped up all over the United States, each attempting to outshine one another with lavish decor, mammoth bowls of cocktails, and, of course, tiny umbrellas and lots of rum in every drink.

The golden era of the tiki bar took place in the 1950s but interest dwindled significantly within the next couple of decades. In the 1990s, tiki saw a revival as a decor style and party theme. More recently, tiki bars have once again become popular.

Much of the tiki culture's (as it became known) downslide is attributed to people realizing that the appropriation of Polynesian and South Pacific symbols and style did not recognize the impact of colonialism on the indigenous people of the islands. This consciousness started in the '60s and '70s and reemerged in the 2010s as an ongoing discussion of how "tiki" (a word referring to sacred imagery of gods) can and should be used by others.

Tiki cocktails are a style of mixed drinks that were inspired by the flavors of tropical islands, both in the Caribbean and Pacific. It is important to remember that they are purely an American invention that came about when people were first introduced to and fascinated by those cultures. Much liberty was taken in interpreting the island style, particularly in decor, though it also produced a separate category of amazingly well-designed drinks. There is a fine line between cultural commodification and respect, and this is sure to be a conversation that will continue.