Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Drinkmate 410-02-3z Beverage Carbonation Maker at Amazon
"This can be used to carbonate any liquid, so you can make fizzy orange juice in the morning or a carbonated Margarita in the evening."
Best Splurge: Aarke Premium Carbonator at williams-sonoma.com
"The housing is made from stainless steel and has a copper finish for an elegant look."
Best Starter Kit: SodaStream Source Sparkling Water Maker Starter Kit at Amazon
"With this unit, you’ll get a small CO2 canister that will get you started, along with a mail-in rebate on your first 60-liter canister."
"A more portable version from DrinkMate, this hand-held carbonator does the same job, but without the stand."
Best Traditional Soda Siphon: iSi Stainless Steel Soda Siphon at Amazon
"A measuring tube makes it easy to add the correct amount of water, and a pressure control valve avoids over-pressurizing the unit."
"Designed with a sleek look and powered by electricity, this carbonator works at the touch of a button, making it easy to use."
01 of 06
Best Overall: Drinkmate 410-02-3z Beverage Carbonation Maker
DrinkMate may not be a household name yet, but their soda makers are quite popular among users. One benefit is that this can be used to carbonate any liquid, so you can make fizzy orange juice in the morning or a carbonated Margarita in the evening. The small footprint of this one takes barely more space than the drink bottle and the carbonating canister, so it’s great for small kitchens, RVs, dorm rooms, or anywhere space is limited. Since it requires no electricity, you don’t need to worry about plugging it in, so you can even keep it on the table. The included bottle has a clearly marked fill line and you can choose to add more or less carbonation for the perfect fizz. Two buttons let you easily control the release of excess carbonation when it’s time to release it. This includes a small 3-ounce carbonation cylinder to get you started. It can accept standard 60-liter carbonation cylinders from similar brands, as well as the DrinkMate branded cylinders. This is available in black, white, or red, to match your style.
02 of 06
Best Splurge: Aarke Premium Carbonator
When you’ve got a high-end kitchen, you want your countertop appliances to look just as nice, like this very stylish carbonator. The housing is made from stainless steel and has a copper finish for an elegant look. Designed in Sweden, it has a front lever that carbonates the water, then releases the excess carbonation for you so your water is ready to go in a flash. It includes one carbonating bottle with a sturdy stainless steel cap. This is compatible with standard 60-liter carbonation canisters that are available in many stores and online, but it does not come with a canister. If copper isn’t your style, this is also available in waffle white, matte black, or stainless steel.
03 of 06
Best Starter Kit: SodaStream Source Sparkling Water Maker Starter Kit
Simple to use, you just need to press the top of the unit to begin the carbonation, and an LED lights on the front indicates the carbonating progress so you can stop at light, medium, or heavy fizz. Bottles insert into the machine using the new snap-lock technology rather than the earlier screw-in method, for easier insertion and removal. If you don’t want plain fizzy water, you can add flavorings after the fizzy water is made from sweet simple syrups to tart citrus juices. With this unit, you’ll get a small CO2 canister that will get you started, along with a mail-in rebate on your first 60-liter canister. It also includes one carbonating bottle. This comes in white or black to suit your décor.
04 of 06
Best Portable: Drinkmate Spritzer Portable Sparkling Water and Beverage Carbonator
A more portable version from DrinkMate, this hand-held carbonator does the same job, but without the stand. While it can accept a large carbonation canister, it’s much more portable with a mini canister, so you can keep this in a drawer at home or at work, or toss it into a backpack to take it anywhere. This uses the same bottles as the countertop DrinkMate unit, so you can give one a permanent home while you have a second one that travels with you. Not only can you carbonate water, but you can use this to carbonate any other liquid, so you can have fizzy green juice for breakfast, fizzy iced tea or lemonade with lunch, then make fizzy wine in the evening, just for fun. This comes in black, pewter, or red, so you can choose the one you like best.Continue to 5 of 6 below.
05 of 06
Best Traditional Soda Siphon: iSi Stainless Steel Soda Siphon
The traditional soda siphon, this carbonates the water in the canister, then “shoots” it into your glass. While shooting it doesn’t make the carbonation better, it does give a more impressive performance when you’re making fancy cocktails at parties. A measuring tube makes it easy to add the correct amount of water so you don’t overfill, and a pressure control valve avoids over-pressurizing the unit. This uses small CO2 chargers, and it uses one charge per bottle of water. It holds one quart.
06 of 06
Best Design: SodaStream Fizzi One Touch Sparkling Water Maker
Designed with a sleek look and powered by electricity, this carbonator works at the touch of a button, making it one of the easiest to use. Just choose the button you want for the level of fizz you desire, and the machine adds the proper amount of carbonation. This includes a full 60 liter CO2 cylinder, so you don’t need to buy anything extra to start carbonating, while the included bottle holds one liter of fizzy water. The bottle has an attractive metal trim that makes it look a bit more upscale. If you need extra bottles, this is compatible with other SodaStream bottles that are available separately, with a choice of different trim colors. While its electrical needs are small, you will need to have a place to plug this in when you use it. This is available in white or black, and also in a bundle that includes three bottles, two 60 liter CO canisters, and two flavored fruit drops to add to your water.
Products Tested by The Spruce
How We Tested
Our reviewers tested this top-rated soda maker daily for three months. They set it up in their kitchens and made soda at different carbonation levels to see how it performed. We asked them to consider the most important features when using this soda maker, from its design to its ease of use. We've outlined the major points here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.
What to Look for in a Soda Maker
Versatility Many soda makers are designed for carbonating water and adding flavor after, but some can be used to carbonate any liquid you like, including fruit juices, cocktails, and wine. If you’re typically making plain carbonated water, you probably don't need a model that’s able to carbonate your iced tea.
Size of CO2 tanks Soda makers can use small (usually 8-gram) CO2 cartridges, medium-sized 3-ounce tanks, or small cylinders (14 ½ ounces, usually described as 60 liters) of CO2 to carbonate the liquid. Some models are restricted to one size, while others can use multiple sizes or even be converted to use the large refillable tanks intended for beer brewing. If you’re planning on making soda regularly, a larger tank is likely a better bet.
Size While some countertop machines are the size of small coffee makers, others are much more portable. Countertop units are usually able to accommodate larger CO tanks — so you won’t need to replace them as often — while portable models are great for tucking into a picnic basket or taking to a potluck or party.
Test Results: SodaStream Source Home Soda Maker Starter Kit (Best Overall)
Easy to use
Customizable carbonation levels
Inconvenient to exchange CO2 carbonators in person
This soda maker came very highly recommended by our testers: “It's so easy to use and gets the water really fizzy,” noted one reviewer. Other highlights were its sleek design and ability to achieve different carbonation levels. “You can customize the amount of carbonation that you put into the water,” explained one tester. “I'm really picky about fizziness — I like a lot — and this machine got the seltzer to the perfect level for me.” The only downside of this soda maker? “You have to exchange the CO2 carbonators in person,” reported one reviewer. “We go to Bed Bath & Beyond, but I wish there was a system where you could mail them in.”