The 6 Best Thermal Carafe Coffee Makers of 2019

Get hot, great tasting coffee with these top-picks

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Black+Decker 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker at Amazon

"The quick touch programming functions make this coffeemaker easy to use."

Best Gourmet: Zojirushi Gourmet Fresh Brew Plus at Amazon

"Has that coffee shop look that you can steal for your very own kitchen."

Best with Grinder: Capresso 10-Cup Digital Coffeemaker at Wayfair

"The slow grinding of the burrs protects your coffees aroma."

Best Self-Cleaning: Mr. Coffee 10-Cup Coffeemaker at Target

"You can clean your device with the simple push of a button."

Best Thermal Control: Cuisinart Elite Thermal Coffeemaker at Amazon

"Internal heating system provides you with three different brew temps."

Best with Hot Water System: Cuisinart 10-Cup Coffeemaker at Amazon

"You can finally perfect your coffee, tea and hot cocoa routine."



  • 01 of 06

    Best Overall: Black+Decker 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker

    Excellent

    Your basic thermal carafe coffeemaker should be large enough to hold you and your partner’s multiple cups of coffee. Black+Decker’s 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker takes on the task with its large capacity, double-walled, vacuum-sealed carafe that keeps your coffee at the optimal temperature for hours.

    This model also gives you the option to use preferred brew options like ‘strong’ for a bolder flavor in every cup. The Evenstream Showerhead ensures water disperses evenly over your packed coffee grounds for maximum taste. The model also features a No Drip Perfect Pour to accompany their wide mouth carafe opening.

    One thing to definitely keep in mind is the extra care that thermal carafes need. Because it’s made of stainless steel, Black+Decker recommends a proper flush using a vinegar-water solution to remove hard water scale from the heater. The quick touch programming functions make this coffeemaker effortless to use. Plus, if you get excited in the AM and need your daily dose of coffee, there’s a Sneak-A-Cup feature which allows you to pause the flow of coffee so you can get in a quick cup mess-free.​

  • 02 of 06

    Best Gourmet: Zojirushi Gourmet Fresh Brew Plus

    Gourmet Fresh Brew Plus Thermal Carafe 10 Cup Coffee Maker
    Courtesy of Wayfair

    It’s okay to want to get the most experience out of your coffeemaker. That’s why Zojirushi created their Gourmet Fresh Brew Plus with a 10-cup thermal carafe. It definitely has that coffee shop look that you can steal for your very own kitchen. The modern appeal is sure to be a major selling point.

    The thermal carafe is vacuum insulated, keeping your drinks hot for hours. If you fear leaving your coffee pot on while running around in the mornings, you can rest assured thanks to the auto shut off feature. The removable water tank makes filling and washing super easy. Thanks to the digital clock, you also get a 24-hour programmable timer so you can wake up in the best way possible—to the smell of your most preferred brew. This model features a clean light alert which lets you know when the device is recommended to be cleaned. No more guessing games!

  • 03 of 06

    Best with Grinder: Capresso Coffee Team 10-Cup Digital Coffeemaker

    Capresso Coffee Team 10-Cup Digital Coffeemaker
    Courtesy of Wayfair

    The Capresso Coffee Team 10-Cup Digital Coffeemaker has a reputation on the market for being a noiseless force to be reckoned with—even with its grinding ability. If you’re a coffee bean connoisseur then you will appreciate the slow grinding of the burrs which protects your coffees aroma while allowing a finer, uniform grind compared to that of a standard blade grinder. Plus, the five fineness settings gives you full control of your coffee experience.

    The 10-cup thermal carafe keeps your coffee warm throughout the day to cut down on waste. You can brew the maximum amount of coffee in just under 10 minutes. The clock/timer feature lets you set up everything the night before so you can wake up to a fresh pot of coffee. The charcoal water filtration system is also a unique selling point; it can remove up to 82% of chlorine and impurities from tap water, which most people use to make their daily batch.

  • 04 of 06

    Best Self-Cleaning: Mr. Coffee 10-Cup Coffeemaker

    Mr. Coffee - 10-Cup Coffeemaker - Stainless-Steel/Black
    Courtesy of Best Buy

    A major convenience for our daily appliances is when they have self-cleaning mechanisms, making caring for them virtually flawless. With Mr. Coffee’s 10-Cup Coffeemaker you can clean your device with the simple push of a button. It doesn’t get any better than that. And this is not a widespread function on other coffeemakers, especially those featuring stainless steel thermal carafes.

    Other functions include a ‘Dim Display’ button, the ability to delay brewing, and the pre-setting of timed coffee. You can also choose your brew strength per session. You can also pause your brewing process to sneak in a fresh cup of coffee. The double-walled thermal carafe lets you enjoy fresh coffee throughout the day from a single batch. There is also a two-hour auto shut off function which safely shuts off the coffee maker in case you forget to turn it off before leaving the house for work.

    Continue to 5 of 6 below.
  • 05 of 06

    Best Thermal Control: Cuisinart Elite 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker

    You can finally have full control of your coffee experience in your home. The Cuisinart DCC-3400 Thermal Coffeemaker uses a unique internal heating system to provide you with three different brew temperatures: regular, hot, and extra hot. The Extreme Brew option uses new re-engineered brewing technology to make your coffee 25 percent faster than the standard coffeemaker without skimping on taste and flavor.

    The backlit LCD screen and the ability to set the brew time to 24-hours ahead are two other features that make this coffeemaker a top-rated model. The thermal carafe is dishwasher safe, and the coffeemaker has a self-cleaning function as well. Available in 7 different colors.

  • 06 of 06

    Best with Hot Water System: Cuisinart 10-Cup Coffeemaker with Hot Water System

    Apparently, Cuisinart is out to reinvent how we make our coffee, and they only get better with their 10-Cup Coffeemaker with Hot Water System. This highly rated option’s Hot Water System makes it irresistible to warm beverage lovers. You can finally perfect your coffee, tea and hot cocoa routine with this magnificent machine. You can even brew a batch of coffee while heating water for your breakfast oatmeal without a hitch.

    Like other competitors, this model boasts a self-cleaning function, as well as and auto-on setting making this machine an everyday necessity for the countless functions alone. You can control your brewing flavor options with just a button, and even use the Brew Pause setting to grab a cup before the brewing process is fully done. The Hot Water System allows you to have hot water at just the press of a lever. Hot water on demand can be very convenient in most households for soups, oatmeals, teas and more. 

Products Tested by

How We Tested

Our reviewers spent three hours testing a top-rated thermal carafe coffee maker. They used it to make several batches of coffee over the course of a few days. We asked our testers to consider the most important features when using this coffee maker, from its capacity to overall design. We've outlined the major takeaways here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.

What to Look for in a Thermal Carafe Coffee Maker

Capacity How many people will you be serving? Do you drink coffee all day, or just take one cup on the run? While the carafe can keep coffee warm for family members with different schedules, if you all prefer different brews you might not need a large pot that serves everyone.

Controls Buttons, dials, LCDs, and touchpads are just a few of the ways you can control your brew or set your timer. All of them will get the job done, so it’s mostly about personal preference, with just a little touch of esthetics. Which do you prefer?

Onboard grinding True coffee snobs will tell you that coffee is best when it’s freshly ground, but many coffee drinkers like the idea of having coffee ready for them as soon as they reach the coffee maker. Some coffee makers have an onboard grinder, so you can grind, then brew.

Test Results: Black+Decker 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker (Best Overall)

Excellent

What We Like

  • Easy to use

  • Sleek design

  • Convenient preset function

What We Don't Like

  • Limited customizing abilities

  • Loud

Black+Decker Thermal Coffeemaker
Black+Decker 12-Cup Thermal Coffeemaker
Black+Decker 12-Cup Coffeemaker
Black+Decker Coffeemaker
Black+Decker 12-Cup Thermal Carafe Coffeemaker

Our testers loved this coffee maker for its functionality and simple, sleek design. “Most coffee makers seem overly complex and unnecessarily fancy,” one reviewer commented. “This one was easy to use, straightforward, and provided all the actual functions I need to make a good pot of coffee.” Our testers also liked that they could preset it to brew at a specific time each morning. However, it does have limited customizable features: “I want to select certain cup and strength settings simultaneously, but it didn't allow it,” one reviewer said.