Our Top Picks
Best Overall: KitchenAid 4-Slice Toaster at Walmart
"Four slots let you toast more bread at one time, and the slots are 1 1/2" wide, so you’re not limited to sandwich bread."
Best Budget: Oster 2-Slice Toaster at Walmart
"This compact toaster gets the job done—and for a fraction of the price."
Best 2-Slice: 2-Slice Breakfast Set Toaster at Walmart
"The wide slots can accommodate thick breads and bagels, and they self-center so both sides will toast evenly."
Best 4-Slice: Farberware Digital 4-Slice Toaster at Walmart
"Each pair of toaster slots operates independently, so you can choose different levels of toastiness for each pair."
Best Long Slot: Hamilton Beach Long Slot Toaster at Walmart
"The long slots on this toaster let you toast breads that are long and wide, so you won’t need to cut your bread in half to make them fit."
Best High End: Cuisinart Countdown 4-Slice Toaster at Walmart
"The lever-free design, digital display, and neatly arranged buttons give it a sleek look that will complement any kitchen decor."
Best Toaster Oven: Panasonic FlashXpress Toaster Oven at Walmart
"This particular model can toast up to four slices of bread at a time or bake a 9" pizza—talk about multi-tasking!"
Best Space Saver Toaster Oven: BLACK+DECKER SpaceMaker at Walmart
"If you have limited space to work with, this toaster is your best bet because since it mounts under your cabinets."
01 of 08
Best Overall: KitchenAid 4-Slice Toaster
This toaster has just about everything you need, in a size that’s compact enough to fit neatly on your counter. Four slots let you toast more bread at one time, and the slots are 1 1/2" wide, so you’re not limited to sandwich bread. Whether you’re toasting bread, bagels, waffles, or grilled cheese it will fit in this toaster.
The KitchenAid 4-Slice Toaster has two sets of controls, so you can choose different levels of toastiness for each pair of slots, or you can toast bread in one slot while you toast bagels in the other. The special bagel function lets you warm the outer side of the bread at a lower temperature while the cut side toasts quickly. The defrost setting lets you heat and toast frozen food so you don't have to thaw it before toasting—and you’ll get perfect results every time. Another great feature is the high-lift lever that raises the toast higher to make it easier to grab.
02 of 08
Best Budget: Oster 2-Slice Toaster
This compact toaster gets the job done—and for a fraction of the price. It’s the perfect size for a dorm room, apartment, or vacation cottage, but it has features that you’ll see in more expensive toasters.
It has seven toasting levels, a bagel setting for toasting one side while heating the other, the ability to toast frozen breads without defrosting, and a warming setting so you can re-warm your toast without browning. The wide slots are self-centering, so thin bread will toast evenly, and the lifting lever raises the bread high to make it easy to remove from the toaster.
03 of 08
Best 2-Slice: 2-Slice Breakfast Set Toaster
If you don’t need four slices of toast at once, the Krups 2-slice Breakfast Set Toaster will save you valuable countertop space. The brushed chrome and stainless steel looks sleek, modern, and stylish, with a blue LED indictor light that shows which setting has been selected. The wide slots can accommodate thick breads and bagels, and they self-center so both sides will toast evenly.
You can choose from six different toasting levels, so everyone in the family can have their toast the way they want it. Not a one-trick pony, this machine has a bagel setting (it toasts the cut side quickly while it doesn’t over-toast the outside), defrost setting, and reheat setting. It also features a lifting lever for easy extraction and a cancel button.
04 of 08
Best 4-Slice: Farberware Digital 4-Slice Toaster
This 4-slice toaster isn't your average machine. It boasts a LED screen that displays the toast level selected so you can see at a glance that you’ve picked the right setting, and the function buttons light up in blue so you can see which one has been chosen.
Each pair of toaster slots operates independently, so you can choose different levels of toastiness for each pair, and the self-centering function lets you toast thin slices of bread evenly. If you need to stop the toasting action, the cancel button lets you do that with one touch, so you’ll never over-toast. The slots are also large enough to accommodate bagels or thick slices of bread.
This machine also has a bagel setting that toasts the cut side of your bread quickly, while the outside of the bagel warms more gently. There's also a setting for toasting frozen breads without defrosting first, and a setting for reheating toast without over-browning. When it’s time to store, the cord wraps under the toaster to keep it out of the way.Continue to 5 of 8 below.
05 of 08
Best Long Slot: Hamilton Beach Long Slot Toaster
The long slots on this toaster let you toast breads that are long and wide, so you won’t need to cut your bread in half to make them fit. You can also toast two smaller breads in each slot, so this two-slot toaster can actually toast four slices of bread at a time.
Customers love that it beeps to let you know that your toast is ready, while the keep-warm setting will keep your bread warm for up to three minutes before the auto-shutoff turns it off (a great safety feature). A cancel button can halt the toasting immediately if you change your mind about breakfast, and it has a bagel setting that is very popular with customers. If you're someone that doesn't like to wait, the defrost setting lets you toast frozen bread without waiting for it to defrost.
06 of 08
Best High End: Cuisinart Countdown 4-Slice Toaster
If you're able to spend a bit more on your toaster, this is an excellent option to consider. The lever-free design, digital display, and neatly arranged buttons give it a sleek look that will complement any kitchen decor. The four slots are extra-wide so they will accommodate thick bread and bagels, and each pair of slots operates separately, which means that you can toast thin breads in one slot while bagels toast in the other slot.
The blue digital display shows a countdown timer, so you can see at a glance how much more time you have to wait for that perfect slice. The bread raises and lowers with the touch of a button, while a cancel button lets you stop the toasting process immediately. An audible alert lets you know when the toast is done, so you can grab it while it’s still hot. Besides seven toasting settings, it has a reheat and defrost setting, which reviewers love.
07 of 08
Best Toaster Oven: Panasonic FlashXpress Toaster Oven
A toaster oven is more than just a toaster lying on its side. It can toast your bread to perfection, but it can also create mouthwatering sandwiches, bake a cake, and reheat leftover pizza. This particular model can toast up to four slices of bread at a time or bake a 9" pizza—talk about multi-tasking!
It has three levels of crust control and preset cooking modes for toast, waffles, reheating bread, baking pizza, reheating foods, and cooking hash browns. An interior light and front window make it easy to monitor the cooking process, and infrared heating ensures that food is evenly cooked. An audible tone lets you know when the cooking is done, so your food will never get cold. As an added bonus, this oven comes with a pan and removable rack.
08 of 08
Best Space Saver Toaster Oven: BLACK+DECKER SpaceMaker Toaster Oven
Toaster ovens are handy, but they can take up valuable countertop space. If you have limited space to work with, this toaster is your best bet because it mounts under your cabinets. Rest assured, it has the same functions as a larger oven. It can bake, toast, and keep warm.
It boasts seven different toasting settings so you can have your toast the way you like it, and it can bake from 200 to 400 degrees. Reviewers love that this is easy to install and the built-in timer works as an all-purpose kitchen timer. It comes with step-by-step instructions and a template for easy mounting.