Our Top Picks
Best Extra Large Capacity Kit: Bayou Classic 44 Quart Kit at Amazon
“...has a 44-quart stainless pot made from 20-gauge commercial stainless steel that can hold a turkey in excess of 25 pounds.”
Best Oil-Free: Oil-Free Electric Turkey Roaster at Home Depot
“For a healthy alternative to the traditional turkey fryer, this is a great option.”
Best Stainless Steel: Bayou Classic 1118 32-Quart Turkey Fryer at Amazon
"Can [also] be used as a very large stockpot for cooking soup, chili, or tomato sauce.”
Best Propane Cooker: Bayou Classic SP10 Cooker at Amazon
“This propane gas cooker can save you money over kits that include both a pot and accessories.”
Best Electric: Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer at Amazon
“There’s no dangerous open flame with this fryer, and the temperature control is simple.”
Best Aluminum: Bayou Classic 3025 30-Quart Turkey Fryer Pot at Amazon
“Lighter in weight than stainless steel, and also less expensive.”
Best Complete Kit: King Kooker Propane Deep Fryer at Home Depot
“Reviewers say this set is a great value for the price, and it comes with all you need to cook a delicious dinner.”
01 of 07
Best Extra-Large Capacity Kit: Bayou Classic 44 Quart "Big Bird" Kit
Cooking for a crowd? Then you'll want a turkey fryer that can handle a large turkey or multiple chickens at once, look no further. This has a 44-quart stainless pot made from 20-gauge commercial stainless steel that can hold a turkey in excess of 25 pounds, so you can feed the whole family and have enough leftovers for lunch.
This includes a vented stainless steel lid, a perforated aluminum poultry rack, an aluminum grab hook, a 12-inch thermometer that reads from 50-750 degrees, a stainless steel seasoning injector, and an insulated glove.
The included burner is the SS30, with a low profile (just 12 inches from ground level) for safety and for ease in adding and removing items from the large pot. When you’re done making turkey, you can use this for boiling, steaming, frying and home brewing. Since the pot is non-reactive stainless steel, you can use it for cooking acidic foods like that giant batch of tomatoes you’ll be canning, and stainless steel is easy to sterilize, which home brewers will appreciate.
The legs are easy to attach and detach from the base with just a single bolt, making it easy to transport or store. This includes a high pressure regulator to control the propane flow and a 48-inch hose so you can position the tank conveniently. While the pot is dishwasher safe, it’s unlikely it will fit in your home dishwasher.
02 of 07
Best Oil-Free: Butterball Oil-Free Electric Turkey Roaster
If you like the idea of fried turkey, but want nothing to do with large quantities of hot oil, the Butterball Oil-Free Electric Turkey Roaster is a healthy cooking option that still produces great tasting results. The double-wall construction uses radiant heat to seal the outside of the turkey and minimize cooking time, and it can handle a turkey up to 18 pounds. If you want to add an extra dose of flavor to your turkey, the included wood chip box allows you to add a wonderful smoked taste to your meat. The tempered lid allows you to watch your food as it cooks, which is another convenient feature.
When you purchase this model it includes a roasting basket with basket lifting hook, removable drip pan for easy cleaning, and thermostat for adjustable temperature control. Reviewers praise this fryer for being easy to assemble, easy to use, and extremely versatile (you can cook other meats in here as well). For a healthy alternative to the traditional turkey fryer, this is a great option.
03 of 07
Best Stainless Steel Fryer: Bayou Classic 32-Quart Turkey Fryer
If you already have a heat source that’s sufficient for heating oil to fry a turkey, there’s no need to spend extra money — just buy the pot and accessories to fit that turkey.
This includes a 32-quart stainless steel pot that is very durable, non-reactive, and easy to keep clean. When you’re not using the pot for frying, it can be used as a very large stockpot for cooking soup, chili, or tomato sauce, or use it for boiling vegetables or steaming tamales.
The perforated basket can be used for steaming, and the lid is vented. The pot has heavy duty handles, so you can move it, even when it’s full. This also includes a skewer set so you can fry three chickens at once. There’s an indent at the bottom of the pot that raises the basket 1 3/4 inches above the bottom of the pot for steaming.
While this is a great deal if you already have a heat source, if you’re new to turkey frying, you’ll need to buy a propane burner as well, or you can buy a complete kit that includes the burner and pot. Turkey frying can be dangerous, so be sure to read all of the safety instructions before starting.
04 of 07
Best Propane Cooker: Bayou Classic SP10 High-Pressure Outdoor Gas Cooker
If you already have a large, nearly 30-quart pot, this propane gas cooker can save you money over kits that include both a pot and accessories. It has a 14-inch diameter cooking surface and low center of gravity to handle your largest stockpots, and wide-set legs for stability. It can handle the weight of cooking pots of up to 100 quarts—more than you’ll need for your average turkey.
If you’re buying a pot separately, an aluminum pot will be lighter, but less versatile since you shouldn’t use aluminum for foods that are highly acidic—just in case you wanted to use the pot for cooking a vat of tomato sauce. Stainless steel pots are more versatile, but are heavier for the same material thickness, and more expensive than aluminum. This cooker has a 360-degree wind screen and operates at a maximum 185,000 BTUs.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
05 of 07
Best Electric: Butterball XL Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer
Sometimes cooking outside isn't always an option, but with an electric fryer you can bring the process indoors. This extra-large fryer can handle a turkey up to 20 pounds and is safe for use in your kitchen. For those that are health conscious, this fryer is designed to use 33 percent less oil so you can rest easy knowing you're eating something that's not soaked in grease. After you're done cooking, the cooking basket makes it simple to remove the turkey and drain excess oil, and the removable parts are dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
There’s no dangerous open flame with this fryer, and the temperature control is simple, with a dial that lets you set the temperature up to 375 degrees. A light lets you know when the oil has reached the proper temperature, and you can set a timer to remind you to check the turkey. This fryer is also extremely versatile, as it can be used for cooking foods in boiling water or for steaming.
06 of 07
Best Aluminum: Bayou Classic 30-Quart Aluminum Turkey Fryer Pot
If you’ve already got a propane burner or other method for heating a large pot of oil, all you need to fry your turkey is a pot that’s large enough. This 30-quart pot is made from sturdy 18-gauge commercial-grade aluminum that’s lighter in weight than stainless steel, and also less expensive.
The Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer Pot is also versatile. When you’re done with turkey frying, the pot will come in handy for boiling, steaming, or cooking large quantities of food. However, since aluminum is a reactive metal, this shouldn’t be used for cooking acidic foods.
This includes a 12-inch stainless steel thermometer that reads from 50-750 degrees, a vented lid, a perforated poultry rack, a grab hook, and a one-ounce trial seasoning injector. Reviewers gave this pot top marks, with one reviewer saying that it "worked nicely and the turkey came out juicy and crispy."
07 of 07
Best Complete Kit: King Kooker Portable Outdoor Propane Gas Deep Frying/Boiling Package
This complete set includes everything you need for turkey frying—and more! When it’s turkey time, the 12-inch outdoor cooker has a 33,000 BTU cast burner that can handle turkeys up to 20 pounds with ease. The turkey rack and lifting hook will help you slowly lower the turkey into the oil and remove it when cooking is done. While you won’t need the lid while cooking turkey, it will come in handy while you’re preheating the oil or cooking other foods. The included aluminum basket fits into the 29 qt. pot, so you can use it for seafood boils and steaming large amounts of vegetables or tamales.
A thermometer with an extra-long probe lets you monitor the oil temperature while keeping your distance from the hot oil, and the regulator is adjustable so you can set the flame to maintain the temperature you need. This cooker also includes a battery-operated timer (requires 2 AAA batteries, not included), so it will remind you when it’s time to check the food.
Reviewers say this set is a great value for the price, and it comes with all you need to cook a delicious dinner. People also love that this package includes an 11-quart aluminum frying pan and basket which can be used for smaller quantities of food.
How We Tested
Our reviewers spent three hours testing one of the top-rated turkey fryers available. To get the most thorough results, our testers set it up outside and fried the birds of their choice. We asked our reviewers to consider the most important features when using this turkey fryer, from its capacity to its safety features. We've outlined the key takeaways here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.
What to Look for in a Turkey Fryer
Turkey capacity Is a small fried turkey sufficient, or do you want to feed a crowd without cooking in batches? While a large fryer will take up more storage space, if a large deep-fried turkey is your Thanksgiving dream, it’s best to get one that can hold your bird with room to spare.
Included accessories Turkey fryers usually include basic necessities, like a turkey lifter to get the bird in and out of the oil. However, there are many more accessories that you might find useful — like a long thermometer, a fryer basket, or a turkey injector.
Safety features The appeal of deep-fried turkey is hard to deny, but cooking with hot oil can be dangerous. When you’re choosing a fryer, it’s wise to consider its safety features, like temperature gauges, easy-to-use turkey lifters, timers, automatic shut-off features, wind guards, and sturdy stands that won’t tip easily.
Test Results: Bayou Classic 44 Quart "Big Bird" Kit (Best Extra-Large Capacity Kit)
What We Like
Easy to set up
What We Don't Like
No spigot to dispose of oil
Shook a bit while cooking
This fryer was easy to set up, use, and clean, according to our testers. And the results? One reviewer, who fried a small bird for 30 minutes, reported that it was “crispy on the outside and moist on the inside.” (A helpful tip: When deciding how long to cook a bird, shoot for 3½ minutes of frying time per pound.) In terms of negatives, one tester pointed out a design flaw: “I didn't like that there is no easy way to dispose of the oil, like a spigot,” he said. One reviewer also cautioned that while the fryer seemed sturdy, it shook a little bit while cooking.