Make-Ahead Thanksgiving Recipes and Timetable

A Make-ahead Thanksgiving Strategy With Timetable and Recipes

Roast turkey thanksgiving dinner

LauriPatterson/ E+/ Getty Images

The traditional Thanksgiving dinner usually evokes weary sighs at the thought of potato mashing, gravy making, turkey carving and getting the entire meal to the table--hot--all at the same time, and all at the last minute.

The ideas in this article and the linked recipes are designed so that once the turkey is in the oven, the cook will be essentially work free on Thanksgiving day until the last 45 minutes. Then they'll simply be assembling and heating food. The preparation and cooking is done, for the most part, in the days prior to Thanksgiving (see timetable following the menu below; see shopping list at the end of this article). 

Several of the "recipes" are guidelines for simply prepared foods, such as baked and stuffed potatoes, cranberry sauce from a can dressed up with Mandarin oranges and pecans, frozen peas enhanced with mint and butter, and so on.

Note: This menu is designed for eight people.

MENU--see recipe guidelines following timetable

Roast Turkey--roast unstuffed to facilitate quick and easy carving (follow instructions that come with the turkey). Work backwards in terms of how long to roast it, so it is done 45 minutes before serving time. A 10-pound turkey is suggested for 8 people, but you may want leftovers.

Stuffed White Potatoes, made one day ahead

Stuffed Sweet Potatoes, made one day ahead

Easy Cranberry Sauce, made 3 days ahead

Minted Peas, made one day ahead

Madeira Gravy, made 2 days ahead

Butter Lettuce with Sherry Vinaigrette, vinaigrette made 3 days ahead

Persimmon Pudding--made 2 - 3 weeks ahead and refrigerated or frozen, with Lemon Cream Sauce (sauce made the day ahead)



I've organized the cooking into: 2-3 weeks ahead; 3 days ahead; 2 days ahead; 1 day ahead; Thanksgiving day.

2-3 weeks ahead

  • Make persimmon pudding 

3 days ahead

  • Make cranberry sauce 
  • Make vinaigrette 
  • Decide on serving dishes; beverages; tablecloth and decorations

2 days ahead

  • Make Madeira gravy 
  • Set table

1 day before Thanksgiving

  • make stuffed white potatoes 
  • make stuffed sweet potatoes 
  • make bread stuffing 
  • make minted peas 
  • make lemon cream sauce 

Thanksgiving day

  • Several hours before serving, depending on size, place the turkey in oven
  • 45 minutes to go: remove the turkey from oven and turn the heat to 375ºF. Spoon excess fat from the drippings and add one half cup drippings to the Madeira gravy 
  • 30 minutes to go: cover the potatoes and stuffing with foil and bake in the oven for 30 minutes
  • Bring the cranberry sauce and salad to the table (toss dressing with lettuce just before eating); carve the turkey; reheat peas and Madeira Sauce on the stovetop or in microwave
  • At serving time: arrange turkey and stuffing on a platter; arrange potatoes on a platter
  • Place peas and gravy in bowls
  • Toss salad with dressing
  • Serve
  • Before eating, place the persimmon pudding in a pot to reheat for 45 minutes (as instructed in recipe--see link). Keep warm by leaving it in the pot with heat turned off if you want to wait a bit for dessert. Serve hot with the chilled Lemon Cream Sauce.


Recipe Link: The Persimmon Pudding (actually a steamed cake) is served hot with a chilled Lemon Cream Sauce and is one of the most popular desserts I've ever made. Best of all, the pudding can be made weeks ahead if desired and refrigerated or frozen, and the sauce can be made the day before.

Easy Cranberry Sauce Recipe: Mix 2 15-ounce cans whole berry cranberry sauce with 1 11-ounce can drained Mandarin oranges and 1 cup chopped pecans. Make 3 days ahead, cover and refrigerate.

Easy Vinaigrette Recipe: Make Sherry Vinaigrette up to 3 days ahead (blend 1/2 cup walnut oil, 1/4 cup sherry vinegar, 1/4 teaspoon salt, 1/4 teaspoon white pepper and a pinch of sugar, cover and refrigerate until serving time). Toss at serving time.

Recipe Link: The Madeira Gravy can be made up to 2 days ahead, refrigerated and heated stovetop or in microwave just before serving. 

Easy Stuffed Potato Recipe: Bake 8 medium white potatoes and 8 medium sweet potatoes the day ahead, cut a slice off the top and remove the insides. Season and mash them, separately, adding salt, pepper (white pepper for sweet potatoes), butter and milk as desired, then stuff the potato mixture back into the shells. Cover and refrigerate. Bake in a preheated 375ºF oven for 30 minutes. Tip: herbs and green onions are great in the white potatoes. A bit of fresh orange juice (and bourbon if desired), and chopped pecans give the sweet potatoes a new zest.

Easy Minted Peas Recipe: 1 day ahead, mix 30 ounces defrosted frozen peas with 4 tablespoons butter, 2 tablespoons water, 3 tablespoons mint jelly and 1/2 teaspoon salt. Heat to melt butter, cool, cover and refrigerate. Heat stovetop or in microwave just before serving. 

Easy Stuffing Recipe: Make your favorite packaged stuffing 1 day ahead, add one half cup drippings from the turkey pan and bake in a preheated 375ºF oven for about 30 minutes--see timetable. You will have stuffing that tastes like it was cooked in the turkey.

Lemon Cream Sauce, 1 day ahead--see Persimmon pudding.




Turkey—minimum 10 pounds


8 medium white baking potatoes

8 medium sweet potatoes

Butter lettuce for 8

Chopped onions, ¼ cup

Green onions for white potatoes

Fresh herbs for white potatoes

2 pounds ripe persimmons

Lemon, 1 for zest + 2 extra for fresh juice

Orange, 1 for zest + 1 extra for fresh juice for stuffed sweet potatoes 


Butter—9 T+ additional for white and sweet potatoes 


Whole milk—1/4 cup + extra for stuffed white potatoes 

Whipping cream, 1 cup


Madeira, ¾ cup

Bourbon for stuffed sweet potatoes, if desired

2 15-ounce cans whole berry cranberry sauce

1 11-ounce can Mandarin oranges

Chicken broth, 3 cups

Mint jelly, 3 T.

Chopped pecans for sweet potatoes

Packaged stuffing mix for 8 

Walnut oil, ½ cup

Sherry vinegar, ¼ cup


Sugar, cornstarch, Vanilla, Flour, Baking soda, Salt, Black pepper, White pepper, Cinnamon


30 oz. frozen peas

See Also 

Thanksgiving Recipes and Menus

8 Roast Turkey Recipes for Thanksgiving Dinner

More Thanksgiving Menus With Recipes:

A Classic Thanksgiving Menu With Recipes

Healthy Thanksgiving Menu