All Tomato Everything - 13 Sandwiches Featuring Tomatoes

  • 01 of 13

    Grilled Cheese with Tomato

    Fontina Grilled Cheese with Tomato. Grilled Cheese Social

    When I think back to my favorite childhood snack, this simple and classic grilled cheese comes to mind. My Grandma, or Meme as I would call her, would make me this easy little dish all the time. And still to this day the melted cheese, the salty tomato, and the crisp buttery bread make me feel happy and comforted. And even though my Grandma probably only ever used cheddar, I've begun using fontina because it melts beautifully and the flavor is remarkable. 

  • 02 of 13

    Green Tomato Jam + Jerk Cheese Grilled Cheese

    Green Tomato Jam + Jerk Cheese Grilled Cheese
    Green Tomato Jam + Jerk Cheese Grilled Cheese. Grilled Cheese Social

    Beecher's Cheese, out of Seattle WA, makes this super special cow's milk blend called No Woman. It's sort of a sweet and spicy jerk flavored cheese that not only tastes amazing but also melts really beautifully. The green tomato jam was store bought, but if you'd like to try it out for yourself, I'd recommend following this recipe from

  • 03 of 13

    Tomato Chutney, Fried Egg, and Gruyere Grilled Cheese

    Tomato Chutney, Fried Egg, and Gruyere Grilled Cheese
    Tomato Chutney, Fried Egg, and Gruyere Grilled Cheese. Grilled Cheese Social

    This hole-in-one style grilled cheese has gruyere and tomato chutney. 

  • 04 of 13


    Bacon, Lettuce + Tomato with Basil Aioli on Brioche. Grilled Cheese Social

    Big crispy slices of country-style bacon, fresh thick slices of salted tomato, sweet, crisp butter lettuce, and a basil aioli that makes you want to lick the bowl all come together between two buttery halves of a brioche bun. If you thought a regular old BLT was good, wait until you try this one! 

    The beautiful thing about these sandwiches? Not only do they hold up really well, but they also taste better as it sits. I imagine this is a result of all the flavors melding and coming together over an extended period of time... eh hem more like everything starts to taste like bacon... but yeah, this is basically my favorite version of a BLT and I'm pretty certain you will love it, too. 

    Continue to 5 of 13 below.
  • 05 of 13

    Tomato, Mozzarella, and Basil Grilled Cheese

    Tomato Jam, Bacon, Pickled Jalapenos + Potato Chip Grilled Cheese
    Tomato Jam, Bacon, Pickled Jalapenos + Potato Chip Grilled Cheese. Grilled Cheese Social

     It makes sense that a caprese sandwich, typically made with tomato, mozzarella, basil, olive oil and balsamic vinegar, would translate well into a grilled cheese. Sure, the classic version is typically made on an un-toasted baguette but who doesn't like crispy grilled bread? Especially when it's rubbed down with fresh garlic. 

    And you might be saying that fresh mozzarella doesn't really melt well - and, well, you're totally right. Fresh mozzarella doesn't typically melt unless it's heated for a long time. But if you're saying "Umm i want my grilled cheese to be oozing with molten lactose-goodness" and if you'd like some tips on how to do this, then go ahead and use some sort of low-moisture mozzarella or any of the shredded mozzarella that you find in your grocery's dairy aisle. It melts much nicer than the fresh version and it tastes pretty good, too. 

    This sandwich doesn't really hold up past about 30 minutes so be sure to eat it right away!

  • 06 of 13


    Hole-in-one Grilled Cheese with Tomato Jam and Bacon
    Hole-in-one Grilled Cheese with Tomato Jam and Bacon. Grilled Cheese Social

    Wisconsin Cheddar, sweet and savory tomato jam, crispy bacon, and a runny egg yolk grilled between two buttery slices of brioche bread come together to make this insane breakfast grilled cheese. And let's face it, after making this recipe, your mornings will never be the same. 

  • 07 of 13

    Fried Green Tomato, Queso Fresco, and Cornbread Grilled Cheese

    Fried Green Tomato, Queso Fresco, and Cornbread Grilled Cheese. Grilled Cheese Social

    Sweet and savory cornbread, milk-y queso fresco, and tangy and crispy fried green tomatoes come together to make this sandwich everything you've ever dreamt about. Eat it for breakfast, lunch, or dinner... or hey, even dessert! 

  • 08 of 13

    Scrambled Egg + Tomato Grilled Cheese

    Scrambled Eggs, Alpha Tolman Cheese, Garlic Habanero Hot Sauce, and Salted Tomato Grilled Cheese. Grilled Cheese Social

    Breakfast on the go is easy with this creamy and rich grilled cheese! Alpine-style Alpha Tolman Cheese by The Cellers at Jasper HIllmelts beautifully alongside scrambled eggs and fresh slices of salted tomatoes. Hearty Texas toast helps keep everything glued together and the Garlic Habanero Hot Sauce adds an extra zing of flavor and helps awaken the taste buds early in the morning. This sandwich definitely will make your breakfast more exciting.

    Continue to 9 of 13 below.
  • 09 of 13

    Tomato and Cream Cheese Open-Faced Bagel

    Open Faced Tomato Bagel. Grilled Cheese Social

    When you think about open faced bagel sandwiches, lox, or smoked salmon, probably comes to mind. Now take that mental image and keep all of its deliciousness but swap out the smoked salmon for fresh slices of tomato and add everything bagel seeds to help make this open-faced sandwich even more next level. The cream cheese is great as-is, but if you're feeling a little bit more adventurous, add some chopped cucumber and fresh mint. You could even add some turkey on top for a little bit more protein. The possibilities of making are endless here! 

  • 10 of 13

    Inside out Herb Grilled Cheese with Sun-dried Tomatoes

    Inside out Herb Grilled Cheese with Sun-dried Tomatoes
    Inside out Herb Grilled Cheese with Sun-dried Tomatoes. Grilled Cheese Social

    An inside-out-grilled cheese made with semi-sun-dried tomatoes, herb butter, olive bread, and burning melange gouda. It's crispy, crunchy, gooey, and oozey all at the same time. 

  • 11 of 13

    Hummus and Pickled Veggie Sandwich

    Hummus and Pickled Vegetable Sandwich. Grilled Cheese Social

     I'll be totally honest here when I say that it's hard to make a vegetarian sandwich that excites me (...unless it's a grilled cheese of course!) But it doesn't have to be like that! Say goodbye to lifeless limp vegetables and start piling on some pickled vegetables, some savory protein-packed hummus, and crisp, fresh produce. By switching up the veggies, you can create a sandwich that's anything but boring.

    A word to the wise though - the combination of the pickled beets and the hummus look awesome together -almost like art- but they also make this sandwich super messy so be sure to use the paper technique to keep the sandwich together. And yeah, you probably don't want this one sitting in a fridge all day, either. 

  • 12 of 13

    Turkey and Hummus Sandwich

    Turkey and hummus sandwich

    The Spruce Eats / Nita West

    Beet hummus is the star of this healthy sandwich. It's beautiful and vibrant pink shade lacks in comparison to its healthy attributions. Beets are loaded with a variety of nutrients and fibers that can help lower blood pressure in just a couple of hours, fight inflammation and cancer, and can help boost your immune system. When you mix the roasted beets with chick peas, which are filled with healthy fibers, protein, nutrients and vitamins, the health benefits keep multiplying. 

    Cracked Pepper Turkey loads you up with even more lean-meat protein while the tomatoes add a nice healthy dose of vitamin C, D and folic acid. The feta cheese is a great source of calcium and the baby kale sprouts are a super food that help boost your brain power with the the green's high level of folate. And although the bread's probably not that good for you, it helps keep everything together and it makes it taste even better! 

    This sandwich gets kind of messy over time, so if you're trying to make it in advance, I'd recommend using a baguette or another type of bread that is more dense so that the liquids from the sandwich ingredients don't seep into the bread. 

    Continue to 13 of 13 below.
  • 13 of 13

    Spiced Lamb Gyro

    Lamb gyro. Grilled Cheese Social

     Crispy slices of spiced lamb, juicy ripe tomatoes, crunchy red onions, creamy tzatziki sauce, crisp cucumbers, leafy spinach and tangy feta cheese are nestled in a buttery and airy piece of pita bread