The warm old-fashioned is perfect for really chilly days when a cold drink just won't do. It's the same great cocktail as the classic old-fashioned, it's simply topped off with a little warm water.
This recipe came from Maker's Mark and the bourbon—with its distinct wheat profile—is a nice choice for a warm drink. Accenting it with the customary old-fashioned ingredients like a bitters-soaked sugar cube, orange, and cherry is a really nice touch. And, as soon as that hot water hits the mix, the flavors open up, melt together, and leave you with a soothing beverage that rivals any hot toddy.
Gather the ingredients.
Place a sugar cube in the bottom of an old-fashioned glass and saturate it with 3 dashes of bitters.
Add the orange slice, cherry, and a splash of soda. Muddle thoroughly. Remove the fruit remnants.
Add the bourbon and finish it off with warm water.
Garnish with a fresh orange slice and a cherry.
Serve and enjoy!
- Not every glass is going to be able to stand up to hot water. Choose one made of thick glass and, if you don't have one, mix the drink up in an Irish coffee glass or your favorite mug.
- When dousing the sugar cube, do your best to get the bitters onto the cube itself. Let it sit for a few seconds so it really soaks in before proceeding.
- Choose your cherries carefully. The average neon red maraschino is actually bleached before red dye and artificial flavors are added. It's better to choose high-end, naturally processed maraschinos or use fresh or brandied cherries.
- The amount of hot water is merely a suggestion. Start small and add more if you like. The goal is to gently warm the cocktail's base, not necessarily to fill the glass.
- The water should not be boiling hot. The average temperature a teapot produces is perfect for this drink.
How Strong Is a Warm Old-Fashioned?
If using a robust bourbon that's bottled at a flavorful 45 percent ABV (90 proof), this is not going to be a light drink. If you pour a full 2 ounces of water, the whiskey is knocked down to a pleasant 22 percent ABV (44 proof). That's a comfortable range for a short, casual sipper and will retain a nice whiskey flavor.